The present application claims the benefit of priority to U.S. Provisional Application No.
62/032,946 filed August 4, 2014, the entirety of which is incorporated herein by reference.
BACKGROUND
[0002] The present invention generally relates to storage of nuclear fuel assemblies, and more
particularly to a facility for wet storage of such fuel assemblies.
[0003] The largest quantity of radioactive (irradiated) material in commercial nuclear power
plants is in the form of spent fuel stored under water in spent fuel pools. The nuclear accident in
Fukushima in which the pools' cooling systems failed leading to severe damage to the plant
highlighted the vulnerability of present day wet storage systems. The Fukushima catastrophe is
partially attributed to the disabling of the pools' pumped cooling systems by the flooding caused
by tsunami and fracture in the pools' reinforced concrete structure by the earthquake. An abject
lesson of Fukushima is to make fuel storage systems tsunami and earthquake proof so as to
prevent damage to the infrastructure (namely the fuel pool, building, and supporting systems)
needed for keeping the spent fuel pool in safe configuration. Terrorist attacks have introduced
crashing aircraft and missiles as Design Basis Threats (DBT) to a spent fuel storage facility.
[0004] An improved design is desired.
SUMMARY
[0005] The present invention pertains to an autonomous wet storage facility for spent nuclear
fuel which can withstand a severe hydrological event such as a storm surge or a tsunami without
losing its heat rejection capacity. The proposed design also envisages a hardened structure that
can withstand a site's Design Basis Earthquake (DBE) and DBT. An autonomous spent fuel pool
infrastructure with capability to transfer fuel from other sites/nuclear plants and to cool and
protect the spent fuel from cataclysmic natural events and sabotage is provided. The
infrastructure further comprises a missile proof and earthquake resistant reinforced concrete
building construction.
[0006] The above design objectives may be fulfilled in one implementation by an autonomous
spent fuel pool storage facility or building that comprises the following: a spent fuel pool; a cask
pit integral to and in fluid communication with the pool; an access bay or staging area to support
1
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
fuel canister moving devices when staging nuclear fuel assembly transport casks; one or more
cranes for moving the casks and loading/unloading fuel assemblies; a pool water cleanup system;
a passive pool cooling systems optionally supplemented by active cooling systems; and an air
lock at the entrance to the access bay to prevent uncontrolled interaction of the building internal
environment with the external ambient air; an air filtration, clean up and pressure control
system operable to maintain the interior environment of the building at a slight negative pressure
to prevent release of air within the building to the external environment; and a missile proof and
earthquake resistant steel reinforced concrete building superstructure that encloses and integrates
all the above within a single controlled building environment.
[0007] In one aspect, a building for wet storage of spent nuclear fuel includes: a longitudinal
axis; a concrete base mat defining a substantially horizontal operating deck; a plurality of
substantially vertical perimeter walls supported by the base mat; a roof spanning across the
perimeter walls; a fuel pool recessed in the base mat below the operating deck and having a first
depth, the fuel pool containing coolant water having a surface level; a cask pit recessed in the
base mat below the operating deck and formed integrally with the fuel pool, the cask pit located
adjacent the fuel pool and having a second depth; a fluid passageway formed through the base
mat between the cask pit and fuel pool, the cask pit in fluid communication through the
passageway with the fuel pool such that liquid coolant is exchangeable between the fuel pool and
cask pit; and an isolation gate movably disposed in the passageway which is operable to fluidly
isolate the cask pit from the fuel pool, the gate movable between an open position in which liquid
coolant can flow between the fuel pool and cask pit, and a closed position in which liquid coolant
cannot flow between the fuel pool and cask pit; wherein when the gate is in the open position,
water from the fuel pool flows into the cask pit such that the surface level of water in the cask pit
and pool equalize.
[0008] In another aspect, an autonomous impact resistant wet storage facility for spent nuclear
fuel includes: a longitudinal axis; a concrete base mat defining a substantially horizontal
operating deck, the base mat disposed in soil having a grade and extending for a depth below
grade; a plurality of substantially vertical concrete perimeter walls supported by the base mat, the
perimeter walls extending upwards from the operating deck and rising above grade; a concrete
roof spanning across the perimeter walls and collectively forming an enclosed building with the
perimeter walls and base mat; a fuel pool disposed in the building and recessed in the base mat
2
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
below the operating deck for storing nuclear fuel assemblies, the fuel pool containing water for
cooling the fuel assemblies; a cask pit recessed in the base mat below the operating deck and
formed integrally with the fuel pool, the cask pit located adjacent the fuel pool and having a
second depth; a vertically elongated fluid passageway formed through the base mat between the
cask pit and fuel pool, the passageway extending vertically through the operating deck, wherein
the cask pit is in fluid communication through the passageway with the fuel pool such that pool
water is flowable between the fuel pool and cask pit; an isolation gate movably disposed in the
passageway which operates to fluidly isolate the cask pit from the fuel pool, the gate movable
between an open position in which the passageway is unobstructed so pool water can flow
between the fuel pool and cask pit, and a closed position in which the passageway is obstructed
so pool water cannot flow between the fuel pool and cask pit; a passive cooling system for
cooling the water in the fuel pool, the cooling system comprising an internal immersion heat
exchanger submerged in the fuel pool and an external air cooled heat exchanger located outside
the perimeter walls, the immersion heat exchanger located below grade and the air cooled heat
exchanger located above grade creating an elevation difference; a closed flow loop formed
between the immersion and air cooled heat exchangers, the flow loop containing a circulating
heat exchange working fluid; wherein the working fluid circulates by natural gravity driven flow
between the immersion and air cooled heat exchangers such that the fuel pool is cooled in the
absence of electric power to the facility.
[0009] A method for storing spent nuclear fuel is provided. The method includes: providing a
building comprising an interior space, a base mat defining an operating deck, perimeter sidewalls
extending from the base mat, a roof spanning the sidewalls, a fuel pool in the base mat
containing water, and a cask pit in the base mat in fluid communication with the fuel pool
through an openable and closeable fluid passageway, the passageway being in a closed position
and dewatered condition; moving a spent nuclear fuel transport cask onto the operating deck
inside the building, the cask comprising a removable top lid and internal cavity holding a
plurality of spent nuclear fuel assemblies; lifting the cask into the cask pit; opening the
passageway which fills the cask pit with water from the fuel pool, the cask submerged in the
water which has a same surface level in the cask pit and fuel pool; removing the lid from the
cask; removing a first fuel assembly through an open top of the cask; moving the first fuel
assembly through the passageway in an upright position from the cask pit into the fuel pool
3
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
underwater; and inserting the first spent fuel assembly into a fuel rack positioned on a bottom of
the fuel pool. In other embodiments, the method further includes: closing the passageway when
a last fuel assembly is removed from the cask; pumping water from the cask pit back into the fuel
pool to dewater the cask pit; lifting the cask out of the cask pit; and placing the cask on the
operating deck inside the building. In certain embodiments, the cask is lifted using a first crane
and the first fuel assembly is removed from the cask and moved into the fuel pool using a second
crane, the first crane having a larger lifting weight capacity than the second crane.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0010] The features of the exemplary embodiments will be described with reference to the
following drawings where like elements are labeled similarly, and in which:
[0011] FIG. 1 is perspective view of an autonomous impact-resistant wet spent fuel storage
facility comprising a building according to the present disclosure;
[0012] FIG. 2 is a lateral side elevation view thereof;
[0013] FIGS. 3 and 4 are end elevation views thereof;
[0014] FIG. 5 is a top plan view thereof;
[0015] FIG. 6 is a top plan cross-sectional view thereof showing an air lock with outer access
doors in an open position and inner access doors in a closed position;
[0016] FIG. 7 is a top plan cross-sectional view thereof showing the air lock with outer access
doors in a closed position and inner access doors in an open position;
[0017] FIG. 8 is a top perspective view thereof from a first end vantage point with roof removed
showing the interior of the building;
[0018] FIG. 9 is a top perspective view thereof from a second end vantage point with roof
removed;
[0019] FIG. lOA is a longitudinal cross-sectional view thereof;
[0020] FIG. lOB is a partial longitudinal enlarged cross-sectional view thereof;
[0021] FIG. 11 is transverse cross-sectional view taken along line XI-XI in FIG. 6;
[0022] FIG. 12 is an enlarged top plan cross-sectional detail view taken from FIG. 6;
[0023] FIG. 13 is an enlarged top plan cross-sectional detail view taken from FIG. 12;
[0024] FIG. 14 is a transverse cross-sectional view taken along line XIV-XIV in FIG. 13;
[0025] FIG. 15 is a perspective view of a nuclear fuel assembly;
4
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
[0026] FIGS. 16A and 16B show two embodiments of an isolation gate operable to close a
passageway between a fuel pool and cask pit of the present building;
[0027] FIG. 17 is a schematic diagram of a passive fuel pool cooling system incorporated with
the facility;
[0028] FIG. 18 is a transverse cross-sectional view taken along line XVIII-XVIII in FIG. 6;
[0029] FIG. 19 is a side cross-sectional view of the immersion heat exchanger (evaporator) of
the passive cooling system of FIG. 17;
[0030] FIG. 20A is a perspective view of the inlet/outlet header and tube bundle assembly of
the air cooled heat exchanger of FIG. 17; and
[0031] FIG. 20B is an enlarged detail of the fluid connections between the tubes and bottom
header shown in FIG. 20A.
[0032] All drawings are schematic and not necessarily to scale. Parts shown and/or given a
reference numerical designation in one figure may be considered to be the same parts where they
appear in other figures without a numerical designation for brevity unless specifically labeled
with a different part number and described herein. References herein to a figure number (e.g.
FIG. 1) shall be construed to be a reference to all subpart figures in the group (e.g. FIGS. 1A, 1B,
etc.) unless otherwise indicated.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0033] The features and benefits of the invention are illustrated and described herein by
reference to exemplary embodiments. This description of exemplary embodiments is intended to
be read in connection with the accompanying drawings, which are to be considered part of the
entire written description. Accordingly, the disclosure expressly should not be limited to such
exemplary embodiments illustrating some possible non-limiting combination of features that
may exist alone or in other combinations of features.
[0034] In the description of embodiments disclosed herein, any reference to direction or
orientation is merely intended for convenience of description and is not intended in any way to
limit the scope of the present invention. Relative terms such as "lower," "upper," "horizontal,"
"vertical,", "above," "below," "up," "down," "top" and "bottom" as well as derivative thereof
(e.g., "horizontally," "downwardly," "upwardly," etc.) should be construed to refer to the
orientation as then described or as shown in the drawing under discussion. These relative terms
are for convenience of description only and do not require that the apparatus be constructed or
5
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
operated in a particular orientation. Terms such as "attached," "affixed," "connected,"
"coupled," "interconnected," and similar refer to a relationship wherein structures are secured or
attached to one another either directly or indirectly through intervening structures, as well as
both movable or rigid attachments or relationships, unless expressly described otherwise.
[0035] Referring to FIGS. 1-12 initially, the autonomous nuclear fuel storage facility includes a
building 20 which is a reinforced concrete structure that is designed to enclose (and protect) the
fuel pool and all its supporting systems. Building 20 includes a longitudinal axis LA, a steel
reinforced concrete base mat 21 that defines a substantially horizontal operating deck 22, a
plurality of substantially vertical perimeter walls supported by the base mat, and a roof 25
spanning across and supported by the perimeter walls. In one implementation, the perimeter
walls may include two opposing end walls 23 and two opposing sidewalls 24. The walls 23, 24
and roof 25 may also be formed of steel reinforced concrete similar to the base mat 21 to provide
missile or projectile impact resistant construction. In one embodiment, a domed roof 25 may be
provide having a arcuately curved profile between the sidewalls 24 to enhance the strength and
impact resistance of the roof, and to shed water.
[0036] In one embodiment, the building 20 may have an elongated rectangular shape in top plan
view in which the two sidewalls 24 are longer than the two end walls 23 as illustrated. In other
possible embodiments, the building shape may be square. The invention is not limited to either
building configuration.
[0037] The base mat 21 may be the same size or larger in dimension than the length (defined by
the sidewalls 24 parallel to the longitudinal axis LA) and/or width (define by the end walls 23
perpendicular to the longitudinal axis) of the walls. This provides a large stable platform for the
building 20 for both earthquake and impact resistance. The base mat may rest on a top of or be
buried in soil26 which defines the grade G.
[0038] In one non-limiting exemplary embodiment, the surface of the operating deck 22 is at
least 5 feet above the maximum 100 year flood level for the site in one embodiment. The spent
fuel pool 40 extending below the operating deck level may be approximately 40 feet or more
deep (e.g. 42 feet in one embodiment). The fuel pool is long enough to accommodate as many
spent fuel assemblies as required. In one embodiment, the fuel pool 40 may be about 60 feet
wide. There is sufficient operating deck space around the pool to provide space for the work
crew and for staging necessary tools and equipment for the facility's maintenance. There are no
6
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
penetrations in the spent fuel pool 40 in the bottom 30 feet of depth to prevent accidental
draining of water and uncovering of the spent fuel.
[0039] The end walls 23 may be at least 6 feet thick with the front end wall 23a providing the
entrance to the facility through an air lock 30 as further described herein. The perimeter walls
23, 24 in this embodiment are built on top of the thick concrete base mat 21 that is at least 40 feet
thick or more depending on the depth of the spent fuel pool40. The side walls 24 may be
approximately 5 feet thick. The domed roof may have a thickness at its apex of at least 10 feet.
The building may be a minimum of 35 feet high or tall (excluding the height of the domed roof)
to accommodate one or more cranes, spent fuel canister or casks traversing the operating deck,
and the cask transport crawler during the fuel transfer operation between the casks and the fuel
pool. The length of the building 20 is sufficient to enclose the pool, the access bay, the air lock,
and to provide interior space around for unimpeded personnel access and equipment movement.
Suitable interior and/or exterior structural steel members that may be necessary to properly
support the walls, roof, cranes, and other equipment or appurtenances associated with the spent
fuel facility may be provided but are not shown for clarity.
[0040] With continuing reference to FIGS. 1-12, the spent fuel pool 40 is recessed into the
concrete base mat 21 and extends from the operating deck 22 downwards to a sufficient depth
D 1 to allow fuel bundles or assemblies 28 (see FIG. 15) holding a plurality of individual fuel
rods to be moved and loaded into fuel assembly racks positioned on the bottom of the pool while
remaining completely submerged beneath the surface level of the pool water W for radiation
shielding purposes. In one implementation, the fuel pool40 has a depth such that at least 10 feet
of water is present above the top of the fuel assembly when moved within the pool and loaded
underwater into the top of the fuel racks.
[0041] A fuel assembly storage rack 27 is shown in FIG. 12 and described in commonly
assigned U.S. Patent Application No. 14/367,705 filed June 20, 1014, which is incorporated
herein by reference. The rack contains a plurality of vertically elongated individual cells as
shown each configured for holding a fuel assembly containing a plurality of individual fuel rods.
An elongated fuel assembly 28 is shown in FIG. 15 holding multiple fuel rods 28a and further
described in commonly assigned U.S. Patent Application No. 14/413,807 filed July 9, 2013,
which is incorporated herein by reference. Typical fuel assemblies 28 for a pressurized water
reactor (PWR) may each hold over 150 fuel rods in 10x10 to 17x17 fuel rod grid arrays per
7
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
assembly. The assemblies may typically be on the order of approximately 14 feet high weighing
about 1400-1500 pounds each.
[0042] With continuing reference to FIGS. 1-12, the spent fuel pool 40 may be formed within
the base mat 21 when the concrete is poured and comprises vertical sidewalls 41 rising from an
adjoining substantially horizontal bottom slab or wall42 (recognizing that some slope may
intentionally be provided in the upper surface of the bottom wall for drainage toward a low point
if the pool is to be emptied and rinsed/decontaminated at some time and due to installation
tolerances). In one embodiment, four sidewalls 41 are provided and the pool has an elongated
rectangular shape (in top plan view) with two longer sidewalls and two shorter sidewalls. Other
configurations of the fuel pool 40 are possible such as square shapes, other polygonal shapes,
and non-polygonal shapes. The rectangular shape with shorter and longer sidewalls 41 is
preferred to limit the lateral span (perpendicular to building longitudinal axis LA) for cranes
which may be used to transfer fuel assemblies 28 between the transport casks and fuel racks 27.
The surface level of pool water W (i.e. liquid coolant) in the pool 40 may be spaced below the
operating deck 22 by a sufficient amount to prevent spillage onto the deck during fuel assembly
loading or unloading operations (reference FIG. lOB).
[0043] At least one cask pit 50 is also recessed below the operating deck 22 in the base mat 21
and formed integrally with the fuel pool40. The cask pit is located adjacent to the fuel pool and
separated by stub wall portions 41 a of the end sidewall 41 between the cask pit and pool (see,
e.g. enlarged view of FIG. 12). Similarly to the fuel pool40, the cask pit 50 includes vertical
sidewalls 51 and a bottom slab or wall 52 that defines an upper surface wetted by the pool water.
Both the cask pit and fuel pool may have a rectilinear shape in top plan view. A vertically short
curb 153 may be provided to separate the bottom walls of the cask pit and fuel pool in some
embodiment (see, e.g. FIG. lOB) In some implementations, two cask pits are provided to allow a
fuel transport cask to be loaded/unloaded from one cask pit while fuel assemblies are unloaded
from a submerged cask in the remaining cask pit and transferred to a fuel storage rack in the fuel
pool40. The cask pits 50 have a depth D2 which is substantially the same as the depth of the
fuel pool40. The elevation of the upper surfaces of the bottom slabs 42, 52 in the fuel pool and
cask pits may be substantially the same. In one embodiment, each cask pit 50 defines a volume
and size which is large enough to hold only a single cask at a time.
8
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
[0044] A fluid passageway 60 is formed in the base mat 21 between the cask pit 50 and fuel pool
40 which places the volume of the cask pit in fluid communication with volume and pool water
W retained in the fuel pool (reference FIGS. 1-12). Pool water is exchangeable between the
cask pit and fuel pool for fuel loading/unloading operations, as further described elsewhere
herein. The pool water depth and surface level 43 in the cask pit 50 is therefore the same as the
water depth in the fuel pool 40 when the passageway 60 is open. The passageway 60 has a
vertically elongated rectilinear shape in one non-limiting embodiment (see, e.g. FIGS. 8, 9, and
11) extending from the operating deck 22 to a point proximate the bottom walls of the cask pit 50
and fuel pool40. Passageway 60 has vertical sides, a horizontal closed bottom, and an open top
which extends completely through and penetrates the operating deck 22. The height of the
passageway may be substantially coextensive with the height (i.e. depth) of the cask pit 50 and
fuel pool40 in some embodiments.
[0045] In certain embodiments, the passageway 60 has a height greater than one-half of the
depth D2 of the cask pit to allow a fuel assembly 28 (see, e.g. FIG. 15) comprising a plurality of
fuel rods to pass through the passageway from the cask pit 50 into the fuel pool 40 while
maintaining the assembly in an upright vertical position with a top of the assembly being space
below the operating deck 22 of the building 20. Advantageously, this allows the fuel assembly
28 to be removed from a cask 300 in the cask pit 50 and linearly transferred/translated to a fuel
rack 27 on the bottom of the pool while remaining completely submerged and underwater to
provide radiation shielding.
[0046] Referring still generally to FIGS. 1-12, an isolation gate 70 is movably disposed in each
passageway 60 which is operable to fluidly isolate the cask pit 50 from the fuel pool40 as shown
in FIG. 9. The gate 70 is movable between an open position in which pool water W can flow
between the fuel pool and cask pit, and a closed position in which liquid coolant cannot flow
between the fuel pool and cask pit in which the gate fully blocks and fluidly closes the
passageway 60. When the cask pit 50 is empty (i.e. no water within), partially opening the
isolation gate 70 from a fully closed position will cause pool water to flow into and fill the cask
pit to the same level as the fuel pool.
[0047] The isolation gate(s) 70 may operate to open and close, and fluidly seal the passageway
60 in any suitable manner. In one non-limiting example, the gates may slide vertically up and
down in tracks formed in the pair of opposing stub walls 41a that define the passageway. The
9
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
tracks may be formed by corrosion resistant metal U -shaped structural channels 71 attached to
each of the stub walls as shown in the partial top plan view of FIG. 16A. Metal or non-metallic
sealing gaskets may be incorporated into the channels 71 to prevent excessive leakage between
the fuel pool 40 and cask pit 50 when the gate 70 is closed. When the cask pit 50 is emptied of
pool water W, the pressure force of the water in the filled fuel pool40 will tend to force the gate
70 against the rear surface of the channels to help promote a leak resistant seal. The gates 70
may be made of any suitable material (preferably corrosion resistant) such as metal (e.g. stainless
steel, epoxy coated steel, etc.), concrete, composites, or combinations thereof.
[0048] Preferably, the isolation gates 70 are fully removable from the opening of the passageway
60 and do not provide an overhead obstruction which might interfere with the underwater
transfer of fuel assemblies 28 between the cask pit 50 and fuel pool40. In one embodiment, the
gates 70 may be raise and lowered, and completely removed from the passageway 60 by an
overhead crane.
[0049] Still other arrangements as shown in FIG. 16B may be used to movably mount the
isolation gate 70 in the passageway 60, such as pivotable mounts using a pinned hinge 72 with
jamb 73 and/or other means to provide a sealing surface. Accordingly, the invention is not
limited by the manner of mounting or moving the gates.
[0050] Referring to FIG. 1-12, the fuel storage facility or building 20 further includes an air lock
30 which is intended to prevent release of the atmosphere inside the building to the outside
ambient environment. The air lock is formed between hinged pairs of outer access doors 31 to
the building and inner doors 32 leading form the air lock into the building interior. A pair of
opposing building interior partition walls 33 provides a fully enclosed air lock when the doors
31, 32 are closed. Walls 33 extend from the front end wall23 parallel to the building
longitudinal axis LA into the interior of the building.
[0051] In one embodiment, the interior of the building 20 may be maintained at a slightly
negative pressure by an appropriately configured and designed air handling system such as a
heating ventilating and air conditioning (HV AC) system. The purpose of the HV AC system is to
provide a means to remove excess moisture from the fuel storage building and to provide for
capture of particulates and harmful gases that may be produced in the building. The fuel
building is maintained at a slightly sub-atmospheric pressure to ensure that its air does not
migrate outside the building. The HVAC system 34 therefore includes appropriately configured
10
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
and selected fans and air filtration system 35 so that any air exchange through the air lock 30
with the outside ambient environment results in ambient air leaking or flowing into the building
and not vice-versa (see, e.g. FIG. 6).
[0052] Doors 31 and 32 may be movably mounted to the building 20 and operated by any
suitable manner for opening/closing such as without limitation, pivoting hinged operation,
sliding operation, or other (see, e.g. FIGS. 6, 7, and 9).
[0053] The building 20 may contain one or more overhead cranes for maneuvering transport
casks and fuel assemblies within the building interior. In one non-limiting implementation, two
cranes may be provided including a (1) dedicated cask crane 80 which may be a single-failure
proof (NOG-1) gantry or bridge type crane with suitable lifting capacity to move and hoist a
fully loaded fuel transfer or transport cask, and (2) a fuel assembly crane 81 which may be a
bridge or gantry crane to perform the fuel handling operation (such as spent fuel pool rack 27
movement and/or spent fuel assembly 28 movement). FIG. lOB schematically illustrates both
cranes 80, 81. Both the cask crane 80 and fuel assembly crane 81 are preferably capable of
movement both parallel to the longitudinal axis LA for longitudinal moving the load and
transverse to the longitudinal axis for laterally moving the load. The cask crane provides the
ability to translocate the cask between the cask pit and the access bay 90 further described
herein. In some embodiments, the cask or fuel assembly crane 80, 81 may be used to remove or
place the isolation gates 70 in the passageways 60.
[0054] Bridge cranes typically are supported by the vertical walls of the building structure which
in turn transfer the load to the floor or foundation. They are typically used for lighter duty
service. Longitudinally-extending horizontal rails are mounted on the walls. A horizontal
structural lifting member on which is mounted the hoist/motor assembly spans between rails on
opposing walls. Gantry cranes typically are suitable for heavy duty serve because they are
directly supported from the floor or foundation and do not transfer the load to the walls. Gantry
cranes generally have a horizontal structural lifting member on which is mounted the hoist/motor
assembly and two vertical support columns with wheels on the lower end which run along a
laterally spaced apart pair of tracks or rails in the floor. Such cranes are therefore capable of
lifting and moving extremely heavy loads, such as the casks which may weight 100-150 tons
when loaded. By contrast, the individual fuel assemblies weigh about 1400-1500 pounds each
(noted above) making the lighter-duty bridge cranes suitable for such loads. It bears noting
11
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
however that a bridge-type crane may be used for the cask crane 80 is the walls are sufficiently
thick and strong. In other possible embodiments, a single gantry or bridge type crane capable of
lifting both the casks and fuel assemblies may be used. Such an arrangement while still suitable,
however, may slow the fuel storage and cask maneuvering/unloading operations of the fuel
storage facility.
[0055] Referring now to FIGS. 1-12, a portion of the operating deck 22 and building 20 between
the fuel pool 40 and air lock 30 defines an access bay 90 for staging the casks and crawlers. The
access bay is sufficiently long and wide to permit a crawler to move onto the bay and lift the
cask offer the crawler and into the cask pit 50 using crane 80. Accordingly, the footprint (i.e.
longitudinal length and transverse width) of the access bay 90 is at least larger than the crawler
and cask. Access bay 90 in some embodiments for example without limitation may be at least
35feet long extending from the edge of the cask pit 50 to the building's air lock 30. The access
bay provides sufficient space for the maneuverability of the crawlers to transfer the transport
cask from and to the cask lay down area in the cask pit. The access bay 90 floor level may be the
same as the operating deck 22 level. The air lock 90 provides the means to bring equipment such
as a cask, into the fuel building without a direct path for interaction of the in-building air and that
outside
[0056] Adjacent to the cask pit 50 and recessed into the base mat 21 is a water management pit
100 that houses a demineralizer skid to clean up the pool (see, e.g. FIGS. 6-12). The
demineralizer vessels are elevated and are provided with a bottom trap door arrangement such
that storage canister (low-level radioactive waste storage canister) can be brought underneath the
vessel. When the resin bed is fully spent it is ejected via the trap door to the underlying storage
canister which is then removed. The demineralizer skid is also designed to provide makeup
demineralized water by taking in raw water (or treated water) from local sources. The water
management pit 100 may have a depth greater or less than the depth of the cask pits 50.
[0057] The water management pit 100 includes at least one hydraulic pump 101 and a tank (not
shown) for controlling the water level in the fuel pool40. Pool water may be transferred back
and forth between the tank and fuel pool 40 to adjust the water level in the pool. The tank has a
capacity sized to provide the necessary level adjustment in the fuel pool.
[0058] According to an aspect of the invention, the pump 101 is further operable to de water the
cask pits 50 via suitably configured and valved piping 102. The same pump 101 or different
12
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
dedicated pump may be used for dewatering the cask pits. Piping 102 includes one or more
shutoff valves 103 which allows either of the two cask pits 50 to be dewatered or for
maintenance of the pump when the cask pits are flooded. The suction of pump 101 draws from
one or both of the cask pits, and the pump discharges the water back into the fuel pool 40 under
pressure via the discharge piping as shown. Either cask pit 50 may be dewatered by closing the
passageway 60 with an isolation gate 70 and then operating the pump 101.
[0059] An incoming makeup water source pipe 104 with shutoff valve is provided to replenish
pool water lost through evaporation. The makeup water source pipe is protected with redundant
check valves to prevent back flow from the fuel pool. In one embodiment, the pump 101 may
take suction from the source pipe to replenish the pool water as shown. In other embodiments,
the makeup water source pipe 104 may bypass the pump and flow directly into the fuel pool40.
[0060] According to another aspect, the autonomous spent fuel storage facility includes a passive
pool cooling system which operates to cool the pool water in the fuel pool even in the event of
power loss. An example of a passive cooling system usable in the present facility is disclosed in
U.S. Patent Application No. 13/450,150 filed April18, 2012, which is incorporate herein by
reference. The passive cooling system is shown schematically in FIG. 17 and 18.
[0061] The passive cooling system generally comprises two major components: (1) an inside
bare tube bayonet type immersion heat exchanger 110 disposed in the pool water within the
spent fuel pool40 (preferably deep such as near the bottom slab or wall42), and (2) an air cooled
heat exchanger 150 located outside the spent fuel building 20 and thereby exposed to outside
ambient atmosphere. The air cooled heat exchanger may be located along a sidewall 24 of the
building.
[0062] The operating or working fluid 75 (i.e. heat exchange medium or coolant) used in the
passive cooling system is a refrigerant with properties chosen such that it boils at the required
bulk pool water temperature (at a moderate pressure, such as without limitation approximately
200 psi). The operating fluid is non-flammable and non-toxic in small quantities. The use of
passive cooling ensures that the spent fuel pool water never leaves the fuel pool building 20
providing additional protection against any inadvertent releases. The pressurized passive system
with a large elevation difference between the evaporator and the condenser ensures that any
break does not allow for the spent fuel pool water to exit the building and also radionuclide
13
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
transport to the environment outside the building through the passive cooling system is
impossible.
[0063] The immersion heat exchanger 110 further shown in FIG. 19 acts as an evaporator and
the air cooled heat exchanger 150 acts as a condenser. There is a significant elevation difference
between the location of the immersion heat exchanger 110 in the fuel pool 40 and the air cooled
heat exchanger 150 located above grade G outside the building walls (see, e.g. FIG. 18). This
elevation difference allows the closed flow loop that naturally circulates the coolant operating or
working fluid between the submerged immersion heat exchanger 110 inside and the air cooled
heat exchanger 150 outside via gravity due to the thermal gradient difference in the closed loop
system without assistance of power or pumps. The passive cooling system thus configured
serves as "heat pipe" that does not rely on any electric power to continuously reject the fuel
pool's heat to the ambient air.
[0064] In one embodiment, there may be multiple (e.g. four or more) sets of bayonet immersion
heat exchangers 110 and air cooled (dump) heat exchangers 150 in the spent fuel pool facility
each operating independently of others to impute maximum redundancy to the cooling system.
Thus the passive cooling system will be online even if one set of heat exchangers (evaporator
and condenser) is out of service. In one implementation, more than four evaporator-condenser
sets each having a 25% capacity rating of the total heat load generated by the decaying spent
nuclear fuel in fuel pool to be removed by the cooling system may be provided to maintain full
100% cooling capacity even if one set is offline.
[0065] The coolant working fluid 75 is preferably selected such that it boils at a set pool water
temperature (e.g. about 150F) and at a reasonable pressure. This fluid should be non-flammable
and non-toxic in small quantities to personnel. Volatility is also preferred for the coolant since, if
a small quantities leaked, it would be immediately vaporized and removed by the building
HV AC system. The working fluid selected will vaporize in the bayonet heat immersion
exchanger 110 located in the spent fuel pool (e.g. at 150F) and the vapor routed to the air cooled
heat exchanger 150 located outside the building where the ambient air (e.g. at lOOP maximum
preferably) will remove the latent heat and condense the vapor inside the tubes. The condensate
is collected and routed back to immersion heat exchanger. A closed piping circuit or loop 202 is
provided between the heat exchangers 110 and 150 which penetrates the sidewalls 24 of the
building 20. This heat transfer process and natural coolant flow circulation is completely passive
14
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
by virtue of the phase transfer phenomenon and the elevation difference between the evaporator
and the condenser. A suitable industrial coolant or refrigerant working fluid for this purpose is
sold under the trade name RF 134A available from Praxair of Danbury, Connecticut. Other
suitable refrigerants may be used.
[0066] Referring to FIGS. 12 and 17-19, the immersion heat exchanger 110 is located and
mounted in the spent full pool and has supports 200 (e.g. legs or skirt at the bottom head) that
allow for the heat exchanger to be mounted on and stand on the spent fuel pool slab or bottom
wall42 (see, e.g. FIG. 18). Heat exchanger 110 may be a bare straight tube vertical unit to
maximize contact with the pool water and aid in natural circulation. In one embodiment a thin
metallic full or partial shell 110a (shown in dashed lines) may be wrapped around the tube
bundle which does not substantially diminish the heat exchange efficiency. In one, the shell 110a
may be of perforated and/or slotted constructions to allow the ingress of heated pool water W to
be drawn into contact with the heat exchange tubes. Heat exchanger 110 may be 30 feet or taller
in some representative non-limiting examples; however, any suitable height, diameter, and/or
number of tubes may be provided. The heat exchanger is preferably a completely welded
construction and the tubes may be a double-walled tube-inside-tube construction to further
preclude the possibility of leakage.
[0067] Referring to FIG. 18, the evaporative immersion heat exchanger 110 generally comprises
a core tube 113 (which acts as a downcomer tube in the exemplified embodiment), a plurality of
heat exchange tubes 114, a working fluid bottom header 115, and a working fluid top header
116, which collectively define a tubeside fluid circuit. The working fluid bottom header 115
comprises a bottom tube sheet 117 while the working fluid top header 116 comprises a top tube
sheet 118.
[0068] In one embodiment, the bottom and top headers 115, 116 and the core pipe 113 are
constructed of a corrosion resistant alloy, such as stainless steel. The bottom and top tube sheets
are constructed of an aluminum clad stainless steel. The heat exchange tubes 114 are constructed
of aluminum (as used herein the term "aluminum" includes aluminum alloys) and are welded to
the aluminum cladding of the bottom and top tube sheets 117, 118 to make leak tight joints. The
core pipe 113 will be welded to the stainless steel base metal of the bottom and top tube sheets
117, 118. Of course, other materials and construction methodologies can be used as would be
known to those of skill in the art.
15
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
[0069] The core tube 113 extends from the working fluid outlet header 116 to the working fluid
inlet header 115, thereby forming a fluid-tight path between the two through which the liquid
phase 75A of the working fluid 75 (coolant) will flow. More specifically, the core tube 113 is
connected to the lower and upper tube sheets 117, 118 of the working fluid headers 115, 116.
The working fluid inlet 111 extends into the core tube 113 and introduces cool liquid phase 75A
of the working fluid 75 into a top portion of the core tube 113. The core tube 113 is formed of a
material that has a low coefficient of thermal conductivity (as compared to the material of which
the heat exchange tubes 114 are constructed), such as steel. The core tube 113 may also comprise
a thermal insulating layer, which can be an insulating shroud tube, to minimize heating of the
liquid phase 75A of the working fluid 75 in the core tube 113 by the liquid W of the pool.
Irrespective of the materials and/or construction of the core tube 113, the core tube 113 has an
effective coefficient of thermal conductivity (measured from an inner surface that is contact with
the working fluid 75 to an outer surface that is in contact with the liquid W of the pool) that is
less than the effective coefficient of thermal conductivity of the heat exchange tubes 114
(measured from an inner surface that is contact with the working fluid 75 to an outer surface that
is in contact with the liquid W of the pool) in certain embodiments of the invention. As discussed
in detail below, this helps achieve an internal thermosiphon recirculation flow of the liquid phase
75A of the working fluid 75 within the evaporative heat exchanger 110 itself (indicated by the
flow arrows in FIG. 18).
[0070] The plurality of heat exchange tubes 114 form a tube bundle that circumferentially
surrounds the core tube 113. The plurality of heat exchange tubes 114 are arranged in a
substantially vertical orientation. The heat exchange tubes 114 are constructed of a material
having a high coefficient of thermal conductivity to effectively transfer thermal energy from the
liquid W of the pool to the working fluid 75. Suitable materials include, without limitation,
aluminum, copper, or materials of similar thermal conductivity. In one embodiment, the heat
exchange tubes 114 are fumed tubes comprising a tube portion 119 and a plurality of fins 120
extending from an outer surface of the tube portion 119 (shown in FIG. 6). In the exemplified
embodiment, each heat exchange tube 114 comprises four fins 120 extending from the tube
portion 119 at points of 90 degree circumferential separation.
[0071] During operation of the autonomous self-powered system, cool liquid phase 75A of the
working fluid 75 enters the evaporative heat exchanger 110 via the working fluid inlet 111 as
16
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
discussed above. The liquid phase 75A of the working fluid 75 is considered "cool" at this time
because it had been previously cooled in the outside condenser unit (i.e. air cooled heat
exchanger 150). As the cool liquid phase 75A of the working fluid 75 enters the evaporative heat
exchanger 110, it is introduced into the core tube 113. The cool liquid phase 75A of the working
fluid 75 flows downward through the core tube and into the bottom header 115, thereby filling
the bottom header 115 and flowing upward into the plurality of heat exchange tubes 114. As the
liquid phase 75A of the working fluid 75 flows upward in the plurality of heat exchange tubes
114, thermal energy from the liquid W of the pool that surrounds the plurality of heat exchange
tubes 114 is conducted through the plurality of heat exchange tubes 114 and into the liquid phase
75A of the working fluid 75, thereby heating the liquid phase 75A of the working fluid 75. The
warmed liquid phase 75A of the working fluid 75 then enters the top header 116 where it is
drawn back into the core tube 113 by a thermosiphon effect. As a result, the liquid phase 75A of
the working fluid 75 is recirculated back through the aforementioned cycle until the liquid phase
75A of the working fluid 75 achieves the boiling temperature of the working fluid 75, thereby
being converted into the vapor phase 75B of the working fluid 75. The vapor phase 75B of the
working fluid 75 rises within the evaporative heat exchanger 110 and gather within a top portion
of the top header 116 where it then exits the evaporative heat exchanger 110 via one or the
working fluid outlet(s) 112 which may be combined into a single line flowing through piping
loop 202. The internal design of the evaporative heat exchanger 110 promotes recirculation of
the working fluid 117 and separation of the vapor phase 75B from the liquid phase 75A in the
top header 116 (as shown in FIG. 18).
[0072] Referring now to FIGS. 12-14 and 18, the air cooled heat exchanger 150 is located
outside the spent fuel pool building inside a semicircular steel reinforced concrete structure such
as silo 210 whose flat vertical sidewall opposite the arcuately curved sidewall212 is a portion of
the side wall24 of the spent fuel pool building 20. The silo thus defines an enclosed and
protected interior space or cavity sized to house the heat exchanger 150. The concrete silo 210
serves three purposes (1) to provide missile protection to the heat exchanger (i.e. condenser), (2)
acts as a skirt to improve the chimney effect for natural circulation and (3) provide seismic
support for the heat exchanger.
[0073] The air cooled heat exchanger 150 may be supported off the flat side wall24 of the
building and/or may have a skirt or legs that rest on grade (which in certain embodiments may be
17
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
well above the pool's operating deck 22 elevation). In either arrangement, the heat exchanger 150
is preferably raised several feet (e.g. 2 to 3 feet) above grade G, which is several feet above the
maximum possible flood level. Accordingly, the heat exchanger 150 is protected from
submergence during the plant's Design Basis Flood. The bottom 213 of the silo 210 may be
open to the soil to allow drainage of rain water accumulated inside the silo. In other
embodiments, the bottom 213 of the silo may be solid or solid and include drainage penetrations.
Preferably, the arcuately curved sidewall212 extends for a depth below grade for added
protection such that the bottom 213 of the silo is also below grade (see, e.g. FIG. 14).
[0074] The silo 210 is open or slotted for the bottom few feet above grade G to provide ingress
for cooling air intake. Ambient cooling air flows laterally through the air vents 201 in the silo
210 and upwards inside the silo towards open top end 211. The heated cooling air is discharged
through the open top 211 of the silo back to the atmosphere (see FIG. 18 and directional air flow
arrows.
[0075] Referring now to FIG. 17, the passive induced air cooled heat exchanger 150 (i.e. air
cooled-condenser) comprises a plurality of heat exchange tubes 154 positioned within an internal
cavity formed by a housing 159. The working fluid 75 is the tubeside fluid and flows through the
plurality of heat exchange tubes 154. The plurality of heat exchange tubes 154 are arranged in a
substantially vertical orientation and may be finned to enhance the heat exchange efficiency
between the working fluid and cooling air (see FIG. 20B).
[0076] The passive induced flow air cooled heat exchanger 150 comprises a bottom cool air inlet
155 and a top warmed air outlet 156. The warmed air outlet 156 is at a higher elevation than the
cool air inlet 155. The plurality of heat exchange tubes 154 are located in the cavity of the
housing 159 at an elevation between the elevation of the cool air inlet 155 and an elevation of the
warmed air outlet 156. As such, cooling air flow will be achieved by the natural convective flow
of the air as it is heated passing over the tubes 154 (i.e., the chimney effect further enhanced by
silo 210). As warmed air exits the heat exchanger 150 via the warmed air outlet 156 at top,
additional cool air is drawn into the cool air inlet 155 at bottom. The working fluid inlet and
outlet 152, 153 of the heat exchanger 150 is in fluid communication with the tubes 154 on the
tubeside via an appropriately configured inlet and outlet headers 260, 261 as shown in FIGS.
20A-B. In the non-limiting illustrated embodiment, headers 260, 261 may each comprise a
18
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
plurality concentrically arranged toroidal tubes. Other shaped headers however may be used so
long as the working fluid 75 may be distributed to and collected from the tubes 154.
[0077] In some configurations, active air cooling capabilities may be added to the passive
induction air cooled heat exchangers 150 by incorporating a motor driven fan or blower 151 into
the natural draft operation if desired for situations where the outside ambient air may reach
elevated temperatures that could negatively affect adequate heat removal from the working fluid
75. The blower 151 increases the heat removal capacity of heat exchanger 150. Such capability
may also be desirable to reduce the pool bulk temperature to low values (say, for example
without limitation under 135 degrees F) to improve the effectiveness of the demineralizer beds
during the (short) periods when the water clean-up system is being operated or during other
building or fuel pool 40 operating scenarios.
[0078] It bears noting that the pressurized passive cooling system with a large elevation
difference between the evaporator and the condenser ensures that any break does not allow for
the spent fuel pool water to exit the building and also radionuclide transport to the environment
outside the building through the passive cooling system is impossible
[0079] The passive cooling system is a completely welded system which ensures a leak tight
system. Small charging canisters of the operating fluid are attached to the system to provide
make up in the case of minor leakages and the charging occurs through valves called low
differential pressure check valves which actuate passively when the pressure in the system line
falls below a threshold value.
[0080] A method for storing spent nuclear fuel will now be briefly described. In one
embodiment, the transport casks 300 usable in the spent fuel storage facility may be Hi-Trac
Transfer Casks available from Holtec International of Marlton, New Jersey. The casks are
further described in U.S. Patent 6,587,536 which is incorporated herein by reference. The casks
include removable lids for loading/unloading fuel assemblies 28 therefrom. In some
embodiments, a multi-purpose canister (MPC) available from Holtec may be used to store the
individual fuel assemblies 28, which canister in tum is then loaded into the transport casks 300.
The casks 300 are transported into and out of the autonomous fuel storage facility via the
motorized crawlers 301. In one embodiment, the crawler 301 may be HI-LIFT crawler available
form and co-produced by the Holtec International and J&R Engineering, Wisconsin.
19
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
[0081] The method may include the following steps with reference to FIGS. 6-7 and lOA-B.
The outer access doors 31 to the building 20 are first opened and the inner doors 32 are closed.
The crawler 301 with transport cask 300 loaded with spent nuclear fuel assemblies 28 enters the
air lock 30. The outer doors 31 are closed. Thereafter, the inner doors 32 are then opened. The
crawler and cask moves into access bay 90 and the inner doors may optionally then be closed.
The lid on the cask may then be unbolted from cask for bolt type closures or seal welds cut with
the lid remaining in place in both cases to maintain radiation shielding of the cask contents. The
cask 300 with lid is lifted from the crawler 301 by the cask crane 80 and loaded into an empty
and previously dewatered cask pit 50. To dewater a cask pit 50, the isolation gate 70 is inserted
in passageway 60 and placed in the closed position, after which pump 101 is turned on (see also
FIG. 12). The pit is emptied of pool water W, but not necessarily dry.
[0082] Next, pool water from the fuel pool40 is introduced and flooded into the cask pit 50
containing the loaded cask 300. In one embodiment, this may be accomplished by opening gate
70 to allow water to flow into the cask pit. In other embodiments, separate piping and valving
may be provided forming a flow path between the fuel pool and cask pit which may be used to
flood the pit by opening the valve. Either approach may be used. The surface 43 of the water in
the fuel pool and cask pit equalizes and reaches the same level, which in one embodiment may
be about 24-30 feet or more above the top of cask to leave a margin of about 10 feet or more of
water between the top of fuel assemblies stored in cask and water level in cask pit for shielding
(see dashed line in FIG. lOB). At this point, if not already done, the gate 70 is completely opened
or removed from the passageway 60 so that there are no overhead obstructions above the open
passageway providing a pass-through to the fuel pool40 from the cask pit 50.
[0083] The lid may then be removed from cask 300 using either the cask crane 80 or the fuel
assembly crane 81 if the lid is not too heavy. The lighter duty fuel assembly crane then moves
each fuel assembly 28 from cask under water through the open passageway 60 between the cask
pit 50 and fuel pool40 and loads them into the fuel racks 27 emplaced on the bottom wall (slab)
of the pool.
[0084] After the fuel assembly unloading operation is done, the isolation gate 70 to the cask pit
50 is closed and pool water W is pumped back out of the cask pit into the fuel pool 40 to dewater
the pit. The now empty cask 300 is lifted out of cask pit with the heavy duty cask crane 80
(while optionally spraying water onto the cask at the same time to remove any potential
20
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
contaminants remaining on the exterior of the cask). The cask lid is placed back on the cask and
closed (i.e. bolted or welded) and the cask is dried by any suitable means. The cask 300 is then
loaded back onto the crawler 301 and secured. The empty cask and crawler may then leave the
building 20 by operating the air lock 30 and doors 31, 32 in a reverse manner to that described
above.
[0085] It should be noted that the foregoing ask unloading process may simply be reversed to
remove fuel assemblies from pool 40, load an empty cask 300, and transport the cask outside the
building and/or off-site.
[0086] The present arrangement with two cask pits 50 and cranes advantageously allows one
cask to be staged and loaded/removed from a cask pit using heavy duty crane 80 while the light
duty crane 81 removes fuel assemblies from a cask positioned in the remaining pit. This
expedites the process of storing spent nuclear fuel in the fuel pool40.
[0087] While the foregoing description and drawings represent exemplary embodiments of the
present disclosure, it will be understood that various additions, modifications and substitutions
may be made therein without departing from the spirit and scope and range of equivalents of the
accompanying claims. In particular, it will be clear to those skilled in the art that the present
invention may be embodied in other forms, structures, arrangements, proportions, sizes, and with
other elements, materials, and components, without departing from the spirit or essential
characteristics thereof. In addition, numerous variations in the methods/processes described
herein may be made within the scope of the present disclosure. One skilled in the art will further
appreciate that the embodiments may be used with many modifications of structure,
arrangement, proportions, sizes, materials, and components and otherwise, used in the practice of
the disclosure, which are particularly adapted to specific environments and operative
requirements without departing from the principles described herein. The presently disclosed
embodiments are therefore to be considered in all respects as illustrative and not restrictive. The
appended claims should be construed broadly, to include other variants and embodiments of the
disclosure, which may be made by those skilled in the art without departing from the scope and
range of equivalents.

CLAIMS
What is claimed is:
1. A building for wet storage of spent nuclear fuel, the building comprising:
a longitudinal axis;
a concrete base mat defining a substantially horizontal operating deck;
a plurality of substantially vertical perimeter walls supported by the base mat;
a roof spanning across the perimeter walls;
a fuel pool recessed in the base mat below the operating deck and having a first depth, the
fuel pool containing coolant water having a surface level;
a cask pit recessed in the base mat below the operating deck and formed integrally with
the fuel pool, the cask pit located adjacent the fuel pool and having a second depth;
a fluid passageway formed through the base mat between the cask pit and fuel pool, the
cask pit in fluid communication through the passageway with the fuel pool such that liquid
coolant is exchangeable between the fuel pool and cask pit; and
an isolation gate movably disposed in the passageway which is operable to fluidly isolate
the cask pit from the fuel pool, the gate movable between an open position in which liquid
coolant can flow between the fuel pool and cask pit, and a closed position in which liquid coolant
cannot flow between the fuel pool and cask pit;
wherein when the gate is in the open position, water from the fuel pool flows into the
cask pit such that the surface level of water in the cask pit and pool equalize.
2. The building according to claim 1, wherein the passageway has an open top which
penetrates the operating deck, a closed bottom, and opposing vertical stub walls formed by the
base mat.
3. The building according to claim 1, wherein the first depth of the pool is substantially the
same as the second depth of the cask pit.
22
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
4. The building according to claim 2, wherein the passageway has a height greater than onehalf
of the second depth of the cask pit to allow a fuel assembly comprising a plurality of fuel
rods to pass through the passageway from the cask pit into the fuel pool.
5. The building according to claim 1, wherein the cask pit and the fuel pool each include a
horizontal slab defining an upward facing bottom surface, the bottom surfaces being at
substantially the same elevation.
6. The building according to claim 1, further comprising an air lock formed between a pair
of outer access doors and a pair of inner access doors spaced longitudinally apart from the outer
access doors.
7. The building according to claim 6, further comprising a first cask containing a plurality
of nuclear spent fuel assemblies located on the operating deck in an access bay formed between
the inner access doors and the cask pit.
8. The building according to claim 7, further comprising a first crane configured and
operable to lift and move the first cask from the access bay into the cask pit.
9. The building according to claim 8, wherein the cask pit is sized to hold only the first cask
and no others at a same time.
10. The building according to claim 9, further comprising a second cask pit sized to hold only
a single case similar in configuration to the first cask.
11. The building according to claim 7, wherein the passageway has a height sufficient to
allow a single fuel assembly removed from the first cask by a second crane to remain underwater
while moving the single fuel assembly through the passageway into the fuel pool.
12. The building according to claim 1, further comprising an air handling system configured
to maintain a negative atmospheric pressure inside the building.
13. The building according to claim 1, wherein the roof has a domed shape.
23
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
14. The building according to claim 1, wherein the perimeter walls and roof are formed of
steel reinforced concrete.
15. An autonomous impact resistant wet storage facility for spent nuclear fuel, the facility
comprising:
a longitudinal axis;
a concrete base mat defining a substantially horizontal operating deck, the base mat
disposed in soil having a grade and extending for a depth below grade;
a plurality of substantially vertical concrete perimeter walls supported by the base mat,
the perimeter walls extending upwards from the operating deck and rising above grade;
a concrete roof spanning across the perimeter walls and collectively forming an enclosed
building with the perimeter walls and base mat;
a fuel pool disposed in the building and recessed in the base mat below the operating
deck for storing nuclear fuel assemblies, the fuel pool containing water for cooling the fuel
assemblies;
a cask pit recessed in the base mat below the operating deck and formed integrally with
the fuel pool, the cask pit located adjacent the fuel pool and having a second depth;
a vertically elongated fluid passageway formed through the base mat between the cask pit
and fuel pool, the passageway extending vertically through the operating deck, wherein the cask
pit is in fluid communication through the passageway with the fuel pool such that pool water is
flowable between the fuel pool and cask pit;
an isolation gate movably disposed in the passageway which operates to fluidly isolate
the cask pit from the fuel pool, the gate movable between an open position in which the
passageway is unobstructed so pool water can flow between the fuel pool and cask pit, and a
closed position in which the passageway is obstructed so pool water cannot flow between the
fuel pool and cask pit;
a passive cooling system for cooling the water in the fuel pool, the cooling system
comprising an internal immersion heat exchanger submerged in the fuel pool and an external air
24
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
cooled heat exchanger located outside the perimeter walls, the immersion heat exchanger located
below grade and the air cooled heat exchanger located above grade creating an elevation
difference;
a closed flow loop formed between the immersion and air cooled heat exchangers, the
flow loop containing a circulating heat exchange working fluid;
wherein the working fluid circulates by natural gravity driven flow between the
immersion and air cooled heat exchangers such that the fuel pool is cooled in the absence of
electric power to the facility.
16. The facility according to claim 15, wherein the air cooled heat exchanger is disposed
inside a cavity of a vertically elongated steel reinforced concrete silo attached to one perimeter
wall of the facility.
17. The facility according to claim 16, wherein the silo includes an open top defining an air
outlet and air intake vent in a sidewall of the silo defining an air inlet, the air inlet and outlet in
fluid communication with the air cooled heat exchanger.
18. The facility according to claim 16, wherein the silo includes a vertically extending
semicircular sidewall which extend below grade, and opposing ends of the sidewall are attached
to the one perimeter wall.
19. The facility according to claim 18, wherein the one perimeter wall forms a remaining
sidewall of the silo.
20. A method for storing spent nuclear fuel, the method comprising:
providing a building comprising an interior space, a base mat defining an operating deck,
perimeter sidewalls extending from the base mat, a roof spanning the sidewalls, a fuel pool in the
base mat containing water, and a cask pit in the base mat in fluid communication with the fuel
pool through an openable and closeable fluid passageway, the passageway being in a closed
position and dewatered condition;
25
wo 2016/022570 PCT/US2015/043625
moving a spent nuclear fuel transport cask onto the operating deck inside the building,
the cask comprising a removable top lid and internal cavity holding a plurality of spent nuclear
fuel assemblies;
lifting the cask into the cask pit;
opening the passageway which fills the cask pit with water from the fuel pool, the cask
submerged in the water which has a same surface level in the cask pit and fuel pool;
removing the lid from the cask;
removing a first fuel assembly through an open top of the cask;
moving the first fuel assembly through the passageway in an upright position from the
cask pit into the fuel pool underwater; and
inserting the first spent fuel assembly into a fuel rack positioned on a bottom of the fuel
pool.
21. The method according to claim 20, wherein the building includes an air lock formed
between pairs of outer access doors and inner access doors, and further comprising prior to the
first moving step:
opening the outer access doors;
closing the inner access doors;
moving the cask into the air lock;
closing the outer doors; and
opening the inner doors.
22. The method according to claim 20, further comprising:
closing the passageway when a last fuel assembly is removed from the cask;
pumping water from the cask pit back into the fuel pool to dewater the cask pit;
lifting the cask out of the cask pit; and placing the cask on the operating deck inside the building.
23. The method according to claim 20, wherein the cask is moved on a rolling crawler.
24. The method according to claim 20, further comprising an isolation gate movable to open
or close the passageway.
25. The method according to claim 20, wherein the cask is lifted using a first crane and the
first fuel assembly is removed from the cask and moved into the fuel pool using a second crane,
the first crane having a larger lifting weight capacity than the second crane.