CIRCUIT BREAKER INCLUDING OPEN NEUTRAL INTERLOCK
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Field of the Invention
This invention relates to circuit interrupters and, more particularly, to
circuit breakers including a trip mechanism, such as a ground fault and/or an arc fault
trip mechanism.
Background Information
Circuit breakers are generally old and well known in the art. Examples
of circuit breakers are disclosed in U.S. Patent Nos. 5,260,676; and 5,293,522.
Circuit breakers are used to protect electrical circuitry from damage
due to an overcurrent condition, such as an overload condition or a relatively high
level short circuit or fault condition. In small circuit breakers, commonly referred to
as miniature circuit breakers, used for residential and light commercial applications,
such protection is typically provided by a thermal-magnetic trip device. This trip
device includes a bimetal, which is heated and bends in response to a persistent
overcurrent condition. The bimetal, in turn, unlatches a spring powered operating
mechanism, which opens the separable contacts of the circuit breaker to interrupt
current flow in the protected power system. An armature, which is attracted by the
sizable magnetic forces generated by a short circuit or fault, also unlatches, or trips,
the operating mechanism.
In many applications, the miniature circuit breaker also provides
ground fault protection. Typically, an electronic circuit detects leakage of current to
ground and generates a ground fault trip signal. This trip signal energizes a shunt trip
solenoid, which unlatches the operating mechanism, typically through actuation of the
thermal-magnetic trip device. See, for example, Patents 5,260,676; and 5,293,522.
Recently, there has been considerable interest in also providing
protection against arc faults. Arc faults are intermittent high impedance faults which
can be caused, for instance, by worn insulation between adjacent conductors, by
exposed ends between broken conductors, by faulty connections, and in other
situations where conducting elements are in close proximity. Because of their
intermittent and high impedance nature, arc faults do not generate currents of either

sufficient instantaneous magnitude or sufficient average RMS current to trip the
conventional circuit interrupter. Even so, the arcs can cause damage or start a fire if
they occur near combustible material. It is not practical to simply lower the pick-up
currents on conventional circuit breakers, as there are many typical loads, which draw
similar currents and would, therefore, cause nuisance trips. Consequently, separate
electrical circuits have been developed for responding to arc faults. See, for example,
U.S. Patent Nos. 5,224,006; and 5,691,869.
Arc fault circuit interrupters (AFCIs) and ground fault circuit
interrupters (GFCIs) can function as a conventional circuit interrupter (e.g., thermal-
magnetic) without connecting a pigtail to the line neutral bus. Without this neutral
connection, the AFCI or GFCI electrical trip circuit is not powered. As a result, this
allows improper use of the circuit interrupter in which it supplies power to a load
without providing arc fault or ground fault protection.
An open neutral condition, which is defined in Underwriters
Laboratories (UL) Standard PAG 943A, may exist with the electrical wires supplying
electrical power to GFCI devices. If an open neutral condition exists with the neutral
wire on the line (versus the load) side of the GFCI device, then an instance may arise
where a current path is created from the phase (or hot) wire supplying power to the
GFCI device through the load side of the device and a person to ground. In the event
that an open neutral condition exists, some GFCI devices which have tripped, may be
reset even though the open neutral condition may remain.
U.S. Patent No. 6,040,967 discloses a resettable GFCI receptacle that
includes a reset lock-out mechanism to prevent the resetting of electrical connections
between input and output conductors if the circuit interrupting mechanism used to
break the connection is non-operational or if an open neutral condition exists. Patent
6,040,967 states that the reset lock-out mechanism can be included in resettable
circuit interrupting devices, including GFCIs, AFCIs, immersion detection circuit
interrupters and appliance leakage circuit interrupters. A test button is used to
activate a test cycle, which tests the operation of the circuit interrupting mechanism.
A reset button is used to activate a reset cycle, which reestablishes electrical
continuity between the input and output conductive paths or conductors. While the
reset button is being depressed, reset contacts are closed to complete a test circuit so

that the test cycle is activated. During the test cycle, a plunger moves a banger
upwardly so that the banger strikes a latch member pivoting a latch finger while the
latch member continues to move. As a result, the latch finger is lifted over one side of
the remote end of a movable contact arm onto the other side thereof. After tripping, a
coil assembly is de-energized so that the plunger returns to its original extended
position, and the banger releases the latch member so that the latch finger is in a reset
position. Release of the reset button causes the latching member and movable contact
arm to move until the contacts are closed.
There is room for improvement in circuit breakers. There is also room
for improvement in circuit breakers employing a line neutral connection to power a
trip circuit.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
These needs and others are met by the present invention, which
provides a circuit breaker including an electro-mechanical interlock. This interlock is
potentially active when the circuit breaker operating handle is in the open position.
The interlock does not allow the operating handle to be moved to the closed position
if the line neutral connection (e.g., line neutral pigtail) is not electrically connected to
a line neutral bus. Hence, the circuit breaker must have the line neutral connection
properly electrically connected to operate the circuit breaker and to energize the
interlock. Otherwise, the de-energized interlock prevents closure of the separable
contacts and the supply of power to the load if the circuit breaker is improperly wired.
An electro-mechanical device, such as a solenoid, is powered from the
line connection and the line neutral connection. When the solenoid is energized, this
disengages the solenoid plunger from the operating mechanism.
In accordance with the invention, a circuit breaker comprises: a line
connection; a load connection; separable contacts electrically connected between the
line connection and the load connection; a line neutral connection; an operating
mechanism adapted to open and close the separable contacts, the operating
mechanism moving between an open position wherein the line connection is
electrically disconnected from the load connection and a closed position wherein the
line connection is electrically connected to the load connection; a trip circuit
responsive to current flowing through the separable contacts and cooperating with the

operating mechanism in response to predetermined current conditions to open the
separable contacts, the trip circuit being powered from the line connection and the line
neutral connection; and an electro-mechanical device including a coil and a plunger,
the coil being energized from the line connection and the line neutral connection, the
plunger engaging the operating mechanism when the coil is not energized to prevent
movement of the operating mechanism from the open position to the closed position
thereof, the plunger disengaging from the operating mechanism when the coil is
energized to permit movement of the operating mechanism from the open position to
the closed position thereof.
The operating mechanism may include an operating handle. The
plunger may engage the operating handle when the coil is not energized to prevent
movement of the operating mechanism from the open position to the closed position
thereof. The plunger may disengage from the operating handle when the coil is
energized to permit movement of the operating mechanism from the open position to
the closed position thereof.
The operating handle may include an insertion barrier. The plunger
may engage the insertion barrier of the operating handle when the coil is not
energized to prevent movement of the operating mechanism from the open position to
the closed position thereof.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
A full understanding of the invention can be gained from the following
description of the preferred embodiments when read in conjunction with the
accompanying drawings in which:
Figure 1 is an isometric view of a circuit breaker in accordance with
the present invention.
Figure 2 is a schematic diagram of the circuit breaker of Figure 1
including an operating handle and a solenoid interlock.
Figure 3 is a block diagram of the circuit breaker operating handle as
engaged by the solenoid interlock of Figure 2.
Figure 4 is a block diagram of the energized solenoid interlock which
is disengaged from the circuit breaker operating handle of Figure 2.

DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
The invention will be described as applied to a single pole miniature
circuit breaker of the type commonly used in residential and light commercial
applications. However, it will be evident to those skilled in the art that the invention
is also applicable to other types of circuit interrupters as well.
Referring to Figure 1, the circuit breaker 1 includes a housing 2 which
is assembled from a number of molded sections composed of an electrically insulating
material, as is well known. Terminals 3 (load) and 4 (load neutral) are provided at
one end of the housing 2 for electrically connecting the circuit breaker 1 to a load (not
shown). A terminal (line), such as stab 5, at the opposite end of the housing 2 and a
pigtail 6 (line neutral) electrically connect the circuit breaker 1 to a commercial power
distribution system (not shown). A molded handle 7 projects from the housing 2 for
manually opening and closing the circuit breaker 1.
As shown in Figure 2, the circuit breaker 1 is connected in an electric
power system 11 which has a line conductor 13 and a neutral conductor 15. The
circuit breaker 1 includes separable contacts 17 which are mounted in the housing 2 of
Figure 1 and are electrically connected in the line conductor 13 between the stab 5
and the load terminal 3. The separable contacts 17 are opened and closed by an
operating mechanism 19, which includes the operating handle 7. The operating
mechanism 19 moves between an open position wherein the stab 5 is electrically
disconnected from the load terminal 3 and a closed position wherein the stab 5 is
electrically connected to the load terminal 3.
In addition to being operated manually by the handle 7 of Figure 1, the
operating mechanism 19 can also be actuated to open the separable contacts 17 by a
trip circuit, such as trip assembly 21, in response to predetermined current conditions.
The trip assembly 21 is responsive to current flowing through the separable contacts
17 and cooperates with the operating mechanism 19 to open the separable contacts 17.
The trip assembly 21 is powered from the pigtail 6 (line neutral) and from an internal
ground reference 20 that is energized by the line voltage of stab 5 when the separable
contacts 17 are closed. The trip assembly 21 includes the conventional bimetal 23
which is heated by persistent overcurrents and bends to actuate the operating
mechanism 19 to open the separable contacts 17. An armature 25 in the trip assembly

21 is attracted by the large magnetic force generated by very high overcurrents to also
actuate the operating mechanism 19 and provide an instantaneous trip function.
The trip assembly 21 of the circuit breaker 1 is also provided with an
arc fault detector (AFD) 27 and a ground fault detector (GFD) 29. The arc fault
detector 27 may be, for instance, of the type which detects the step increases in
current which occur each time an arc is struck, although other types of arc fault
detectors could also be used. Suitable arc fault detectors are disclosed, for instance, in
U.S. Patent No. 5,224,006, with a preferred type described in U.S. Patent No.
5,691,869 which is hereby incorporated by reference. The arc fault detector 27 senses
the current in the electrical system 11 by monitoring the voltage across the bimetal 23
through the lead 31 to sense an arc fault current condition. As described in Patent
5,691,869, the arc fault detector 27 includes circuitry which generates a pulse in
response to each step change in current. The pulse signal is integrated with the result
of the integration being attenuated over time. When the time attenuated accumulation
of the pulses reaches a selected level, the arc fault detector 27 generates at its output
an arc fault trip signal 32 which is active in response to the arc fault. In turn, the
signal 32 is combined with a ground fault trip signal 33 of the ground fault detector 29
and is employed to actuate the operating mechanism 19 and open the separable
contacts 17 in response to the fault.
The ground fault detector 29 may be of the well known dormant
oscillator type in which case it utilizes a pair of sensing coils 34,35 to detect both line-
to-ground and neutral-to-ground fault current conditions. If the arc fault detector 27
detects an arc fault in the electric power system 11, the trip signal 32 is generated
which turns on a switch such as the silicon controlled rectifier (SCR) 37 to energize a
trip solenoid 39. When the ground fault detector 29 detects a ground fault, it
generates at its output the ground fault trip signal 33 which is active in response to the
ground fault. The ground fault trip signal 33 is "ORed" with the arc fault trip signal
32 (i.e., an "OR" function of the outputs of the ground fault detector 29 and the arc
fault detector 27), such that the combination of the signals 32,33 forms a fault
protection trip signal 41.
Under normal operation, the trip signal 41 turns the SCR 37 on,
energizes the trip solenoid 39 and, thereby, actuates the operating mechanism 19 to

open the separable contacts 17 in response to the arc fault or ground fault. A resistor
43 in series with the coil of the solenoid 39 limits the coil current and a capacitor 44
protects the gate of the SCR 37 from voltage spikes and false tripping due to noise. In
this manner, either the arc fault condition or the ground fault condition results in the
interruption of electrical power independent of the other.
Both the arc fault detector 27 and the ground fault detector 29 may
have test circuits (not shown).
In accordance with the invention, a suitable electro-mechanical
interlock, such as solenoid 50, is potentially active when the circuit breaker operating
handle 7 is in the open position (as shown in Figure 1). The solenoid 50 includes a
coil 51, which is powered from a line connection 52 to the stab 5 (line) and a neutral
connection 54 to the pigtail 6 (line neutral).
When the solenoid 50 is energized, the solenoid plunger 56 disengages
from the operating handle 7 to permit movement of the operating mechanism 19 from
the open position to the closed position thereof. For example, this removes the
solenoid plunger 56 from a portion of the operating handle 7 as is shown in Figure 4.
As shown in Figure 3, the operating handle 7 includes an insertion barrier 58 with an
opening 60 (shown in hidden line drawing) therein. The solenoid plunger 56 engages
the operating handle 7 at the opening 60 when the solenoid coil 51 is not energized to
prevent movement of the operating handle 7 from the open position (Figure 3) to the
closed position (shown in phantom line drawing in Figure 4) thereof. Otherwise,
when the solenoid 50 is de-energized (e.g., when the pigtail 6 (Figure 1) is not
electrically connected to a suitable line neutral bus), the solenoid plunger 56 engages
a portion of the operating handle 7 as shown in Figure 3, which prevents movement of
the operating mechanism 19 from the open position to the closed position thereof and
does not allow the operating handle 7 to be moved to its closed position (as shown in
phantom line drawing in Figure 4). Hence, the circuit breaker 1 must have the pigtail
6 properly electrically connected to energize the solenoid 50 and, thus, operate the
circuit breaker 1. Otherwise, the solenoid 50 prevents closure of the separable
contacts 17 and the supply of power to the load terminal 3 if the circuit breaker 1 is
improperly wired.

If the pigtail 6 is removed from the line neutral bus (not shown) when
the circuit breaker 1 is on, then the solenoid plunger 56 re-engages the operating
handle 7 at the opening 60 when the circuit breaker 1 is turned off or is reset after a
trip condition.
The arc fault detector 27 and/or the ground fault detector 29 may
employ a combination of one or more of analog, digital and/or processor-based
circuits.
Although both the arc fault detector 27 and the ground fault detector 29
are disclosed, one or both of those detectors 27,29 and/or any suitable trip circuit may
be employed.
While specific embodiments of the invention have been described in
detail, it will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that various modifications and
alternatives to those details could be developed in light of the overall teachings of the
disclosure. Accordingly, the particular arrangements disclosed are meant to be
illustrative only and not limiting as to the scope of the invention which is to be given
the full breadth of the claims appended and any and all equivalents thereof.

What is Claimed is:
1. A circuit breaker (1) comprising:
a line connection (5);
a load connection (3);
separable contacts (17) electrically connected between said line
connection and said load connection;
a line neutral connection (6);
an operating mechanism (19) adapted to open and close said
separable contacts, said operating mechanism moving between an open position
wherein said line connection is electrically disconnected from said load connection
and a closed position wherein said line connection is electrically connected to said
load connection;
a trip circuit (21) responsive to current flowing through said
separable contacts and cooperating with said operating mechanism in response to
predetermined current conditions to open said separable contacts, said trip circuit
being powered from said line connection and said line neutral connection; and
an electro-mechanical device (50) including a coil (51) and a
plunger (56), said coil being energized from said line connection and said line neutral
connection, said plunger engaging said operating mechanism when said coil is not
energized to prevent movement of said operating mechanism from the open position
to the closed position thereof, said plunger disengaging from said operating
mechanism when said coil is energized to permit movement of said operating
mechanism from the open position to the closed position thereof.
2. The circuit breaker (1) of Claim 1 wherein said line connection
is a line terminal (5) and said load connection is a load terminal (3).
3. The circuit breaker (1) of Claim 1 wherein said line neutral
connection is a line neutral pigtail (6).
4. The circuit breaker (1) of Claim 1 wherein said operating
mechanism includes an operating handle (7); and wherein said plunger engages said
operating handle when said coil is not energized to prevent movement of said
operating mechanism from the open position to the closed position thereof, said
plunger disengaging from said operating handle when said coil is energized to permit

movement of said operating mechanism from the open position to the closed position
thereof.
5. The circuit breaker (1) of Claim 4 wherein said operating
handle includes an insertion barrier (58); and wherein said plunger engages the
insertion barrier of said operating handle when said coil is not energized to prevent
movement of said operating mechanism from the open position to the closed position
thereof.
6. The circuit breaker (1) of Claim 1 wherein said trip circuit
includes a ground fault trip circuit (29) powered from said line connection and said
line neutral connection.
7. The circuit breaker (1) of Claim 1 wherein said trip circuit
includes an arc fault trip circuit (27) powered from said line connection and said line
neutral connection.
8. The circuit breaker (1) of Claim 1 wherein said trip circuit
includes an arc fault trip circuit (27) and a ground fault trip circuit (29) powered from
said line connection and said line neutral connection.
9. The circuit breaker (1) of Claim 1 wherein said electro-
mechanical device is a solenoid (50).
10. The circuit breaker (1) of Claim 1 wherein said trip circuit is
powered from said line neutral connection and from said line connection when said
separable contacts are closed.
11. The circuit breaker (1) of Claim 1 wherein the coil of said
electro-mechanical device is directly powered from said line connection and said line
neutral connection.

A circuit breaker includes line and load terminals, separable contacts
electrically connected between the line and load terminals, and a line neutral pigtail.
An operating mechanism including an operating handle is adapted to open and close
the contacts. A trip circuit responds to current flowing through the contacts and
cooperates with the operating mechanism in response to predetermined current
conditions to open the contacts. The trip circuit is powered from the line terminal and
the line neutral pigtail. A solenoid includes a plunger and a coil, which is energized
from the line terminal and the line neutral pigtail. The plunger engages the operating
handle when the coil is not energized to prevent movement of the handle from the
open to the closed position thereof. The plunger disengages from the operating
handle when the coil is energized to permit movement of the handle from the open to
the closed position thereof.