Abstract: The invention relates to a method for preparing a combretastatin derivative (I) or (II), said method including the following steps: triaryl(3,4,5- trimethoxybenzyl)phosphonium halide P3 (III), wherein Ar denotes an aryl group selected from among phenyl or thienyl, is reacted with P2 having formula (IV) or P"2 having formula (V) so as to respectively obtain the compound P4 or P"4, which have formulas (VI) and (VII), respectively; then, during a step for deprotection in the presence of an acid and/or a base, the compound having P4 or P"4 leads, after an optional purification step, to the compound having formula (I) or (II).
COMBRETASTATIN DERIVATIVE PREPARATION METHOD
The present patent application relates to a process for the preparation of a combretastatin
derivative of formula (I) or (II):
A" denoting the anion associated with an acid AH. More particularly, A denotes Ci".
[Technical problem]
The compounds (I) and (II) belong to the family of the combretastatin derivatives or stilbene
derivatives which are anticancer compounds. They are described in Applications
EP 0 731 085, EP 1 264 821, EP 1 068 870 and EP 1 407 784. The preparation of these
derivatives is based, in one of the stages, on the formation of the C=C double bond. In this
stage, two isomers Z and E may be formed but only the Z isomer exhibits a
truly effective anticancer activity. The preparation process should thus result in a high Z/E
ratio.
The Applicant Company has developed an alternative process for the preparation of the
compounds (I) and (II) which is based on the use of the intermediates P2 or P'2 described
below. This process exhibits the advantage of eliminating the stage during which a cytotoxic
intermediate is formed. This alternative process thus exhibits fewer stages comprising toxic
compounds, which makes it easier to manage it from an industrial viewpoint.
[Prior art]
The papers J.FIuor.Chem., 2003, 123, 101-108, and Synlett., 2006, 18, 2977, describe the
preparation of combretastatins using one of the stages of the Wittig reaction. The Wittig
reaction is also envisaged in Patent US 7 265136 and in International Applications
WO 03/084919 and WO 2009/118474.
[Brief description of the invention]
The invention relates to a process for the preparation of a combretastatin derivative of
formula (I) or (II):
A" denoting the anion associated with an acid AH, comprising the following stages:
• triaryl(3,4,5-trimethoxybenzy!)phosphonium hafide P3
in which Ar denotes an aryl group chosen from phenyl orthienyl, optionally substituted by
a (C1-C4)alkyl, (C1-C4)alkoxy or halogen group, is reacted, in the presence of a base, with:
- P2 of formula:
in which R and R' represent:
o each a (C1-C4)alkyl group;
o or else R represents a phenyl group optionally substituted by a (C1-C4)alkoxy
group and R' represents a hydrogen atom;
o or else R and R' form, together with the carbon atom to which they are connected,
a (C3-C7)cycloalkyl group;
- or else P'2 of formula:
in which PG1 represents a protective group for the alcohol functional group,
X representing boc, Fmoc or CBZ,
so as to respectively obtain the compound P4 or P'4:
• then, during a deprotection stage in the presence of an acid and/or of a base, the
compound of formula P4 or P'4 results, after an optional purification stage, in the
compound of formula (I) or (II).
The invention also relates to a compound of formula P2:
in which R and R' represent:
o each a (C1-C4)aikyl group;
o or else R represents a phenyl group optionally substituted by a (C1-C4)alkoxy
group and R' represents a hydrogen atom;
o or else R and R' form, together with the carbon atom to which they are connected,
a (C3-C7)cycloalkyl group;
and X represents boc, Fmoc or CBZ.
The invention also relates to the compound of formula P'2:
in which PG1 represents a protective group for the alcohol functional group and X
represents boc, Fmoc or CBZ.
R and R' can, for example, both represent a methyl (Me) group or can form, together with
the carbon atom to which they are connected, the cyclohexyl group. X can, for example,
represent boc. PG1 can, for example, represent one of the following protective groups; THP
(tetrahydropyran), MEM (methoxyethoxymethyl), boc, trityl or acetyl (Ac). Ar can
represent the phenyl or thienyl group, optionally substituted by a (C1-C4)alkyl or
(C1-C4)alkoxy group. A" can denote CI".
The invention also relates to the use of one of the two compounds P2 and P'2 as
intermediate in the preparation of a compound of formula (I) or (II).
The invention also relates to the use of one of the two compounds P4 and P'4 as
intermediate in the preparation of a compound of formula (I) or (II).
[Detailed description of the invention]
The general Scheme 1 describes stages (i) to (iv) of the process:
Stage i\Y coupling of 3-amino-4-methoxybenza!dehyde and of a protected serine of
formula:
• P1( in which R and R' represent:
o each a (C1-C4)alkyi group;
o or else R represents a phenyl group optionally substituted by a (C1-C4)alkoxy
group, for example methoxy, and R' represents a hydrogen atom;
o or else R and R' form, together with the carbon atom to which they are
connected, a (C3-C7)cycloalkyl group;
• or else of formula P'1, in which PG1 represents a protective group for the alcohol
functional group. On conclusion of this coupling, P2 or P'2 respectively is obtained.
• X represents boc, Fmoc or CBZ.
P1 can more particularly be one of the following compounds:
and in particular those for which X = boc (for example,
compound 8 of Synthesis, 2006, 8, 1289-1294, for which R = R' = Me).
P'1 can more particularly be one of the following compounds:
X = boc, PG1 = THP: see compound 13a of Ex. 13 of WO 06042215;
X = PG1 = boc: Justus Liebigs Annaieri der Chemie, 1971, 743, 57-68;
X = Fmoc, PG1 = Ac: commercial compound of formula:
PG1 denotes a protective group for the alcohol functional group, boc, Fmoc and CBZ
respectively denote the tert-butoxycarbonyl, 9-fiuorenylmethoxycarbonyl and
benzyloxycarbonyl groups. A protective group is a chemical entity which is introduced onto
a molecule during a "protection" stage by modification of a chemical group, making it
possible to improve the chemoselectivity of a reaction by preventing undesirable side
reactions at the said chemical group, and which is released during a subsequent
"deprotection" stage. PG1 can, for example, be THP (tetrahydropyran), MEM
(methoxyethoxymethyl), boc, trityl or acetyl (Ac).
The coupling (amidation) is advantageously carried out in the presence of an acid activator.
The term "acid activator" denotes a compound having the role of rendering the acid
functional group -COOH of P1 or P'1 more reactive for the purpose of promoting the
formation of an amide bond. Reference may be made, for further details with regard to acid
activators, to the review ChemFiles, Vol. 7, No. 2, page 3, edited by Aidrich Chemical, or
else to Tetrahedron Report, No. 672, 2004, 60, 2447-2467, "Recent development of peptide
coupling reagents in organic synthesis". EDCI (1-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)-3-
ethylcarbodiimide) chloride), DCC (dicyclohexylcarbodiimide), TOTU
(0-[ethoxycarbonyl]cyanomethyleneamino)-N,N,N',N'-tetramethyluronium tetrafluoroborate),
HBTU (O-(benzotriazol-l-yl)-N.N.N'.N'-tetramethyluronium hexafluorophosphate) and N,N-
carbonyidiimidazole are examples of acid activators or the anhydride of propanephosphonic
acid (T3P). In the presence of the acid activator, an isolable or non-isolable intermediate
may be formed which comprises an activated acid functional group of the form -COZ; for
example, in the case of pivaloyl chloride, Z represents -OtBu.
The coupling can be carried out in a solvent, such as, for example, a chlorinated solvent, for
example dichloromethane (DCM), an ether, for example THF, or an aromatic solvent, for
example toluene, at a temperature which can be between 0°C and 20°C.
Stage (ii): Wittig reaction between P2 or P'2 and triaryl(3,4,5-trimethoxybenzyl)phosphonium
halide P3, resulting respectively in P4 or P'4. In P3, Ar denotes an aryl group chosen from
phenyl or thienyf, optionally substituted by a (C1-C4)alkyl or (C1-C4)alkoxy group.
The Wittig reaction is carried out in a solvent in the presence of base. P3 is obtained by the
reaction of 3,4,5-trimethoxybenzyl halide with the corresponding triarylphosphine PAr3. Use
is preferably made of a chloride or a bromide. An example of P3 is triphenyl(3,4,5-
trimethoxybenzyi)phosphonium chloride, which is described on p. 102 of J. Fluor. Chem.,
2003, 123, 101-108, or else its bromide equivalent, which is described on pp. 15-16 of
WO 02/06279.
The solvent of this reaction can, for example, be toluene, THF, dimethylformamide (DMF),
chloroform, DCM, trifluorotoluene, a mixture of these solvents or an aqueous two-phase
mixture, such as, for example, the chloroform/water mixture.
The base which is used is preferably a strong base, such as, for example, NaHMDS
(sodium bis(trimethylsi!yl)amide; CAS [1070-89-9]), KHMDS (potassium
bis(trimethylsilyl)amide; CAS [40949-94-8]), sodium methoxide, sodium amide or sodium
hydroxide. The base can be brought together with a phosphonium salt P3 and then the
aldehyde P2 or P'2 can be run onto the phosphonium salt P3, which will have been brought
into contact beforehand with the base. According to a preferred alternative form which
makes it possible to obtain a higher yield of P4 or P'4, the base is run onto the mixture
formed by the aldehyde and the phosphonium salt.
The Wittig reaction can be carried out at a temperature generally of between 0°C and the
reflux temperature of the solvent.
Stage fiii): the deprotection of P4 or P'4 is carried out in one or more stages and under
conditions which depend on the nature of the protective groups X and, if appropriate, PG1. A
person skilled in the art may refer to "Greene's Protective Groups in Organic Synthesis",
4th edition, ISBN 978-0-471 -69754-1, to find, if appropriate, these conditions.
Thus, for some protective groups (for example, compound P4 with X = boc), the
deprotection can be carried out in the presence of an organic or inorganic acid AH. In
this case, the deprotection results in the compound P5 in the salt form. For other
protective groups, the deprotection can be carried out in the presence of an organic or
inorganic base B. In this case, the deprotection results in the compound P'5 in the base
form. The temperature of the deprotection reaction is preferably between 0°C and 50°C.
The acid can be a strong acid, such as, for example, hydrochloric acid, which results in
the hydrochloride. The base can be, for example, sodium hydroxide. It is also possible
to combine an acid treatment and a basic treatment, in particular for P'4, which
comprises two different protective groups X and PG1.
Stage (iv): if necessary, the Z isomer is separated from the E isomer by any purification
technique known in organic synthesis. It can be purification by recrystallization, using as
solvent a mixture comprising an alcohol and a ketone or an ester and more particularly the
methyl ethyl ketone (MEK)/water mixture.
Stage (iii) or, if appropriate, (iv) can optionally be followed by an additional stage consisting
in converting:
- by addition of an acid, a combretastatin in the base form (for example (II)) into
combretastatin in the salt form (for example (I))
or else, by addition of a base, the combretastatin in the salt form (for example (I)) into
combretastatin in the base form (form example (II)).
Intermediates P1 and P'1
P1 is obtained according to Scheme 2 by reaction of a ketone and of a derivative of L-
serine, the amine functional group of which has been protected with X.
P'1 is obtained by protection of the -OH functional group of a derivative of L-serine, the
amine functional group of which has been protected with X.
The derivative of L-serine of Schemes 2 and 2' can be commercially available (for example,
N-boc-L-serine) or readily accessible using at least one chemical reaction known to a
person skilled in the art (similar, for example, to that which makes it possible to prepare
N-boc-L-serine).
3-Amino-4-methoxybenzaldehyde is obtained by reduction of the corresponding nitro
compound according to Tetrahedron Letters, 1993, 34(46), 7445-1446.
Before being used, the reactor is freed with DCM, dried under vacuum and purged by
flushing with nitrogen for 15 to 30 min, the Erienmeyer flask is rinsed with amylene-
stabilized DCM and then dried under nitrogen. 95 ml of DCM and 34.0 g of boc-L-serine
acetonide are charged to the reactor, the reactor is cooled to 4-10°C and 14.3 g of
N-methylmorpholine are added using a dropping funnel while maintaining the temperature
at 4-10°C. The dropping funnel is rinsed with 2.5 ml of DCM. 17.1 g of pivaloyl chloride are
added using a dropping funnel while maintaining the temperature at 4-10°C and the
dropping funnel is rinsed with 2.5 ml of DCM. The mixture is kept stirred at 4-10°C for 2 h.
A solution of aminobal (20.0 g) in DCM (95 ml) is prepared with stirring and this solution is
run into the reactor while maintaining the temperature at 4-10°C. The mixture is
subsequently heated to 20°C over 1 h and is kept stirred at 20°C for a minimum of 16 h.
100 ml of demineraiized water are added to the reactor at 20-25°C and the mixture is left
stirring for 20 min and separated by settling. The lower organic phase comprising the
product and the upper phase (predominantly aqueous) are withdrawn. The organic phase
comprising the product is again charged to the reactor. 140 ml of a 1.0N aqueous sodium
hydroxide solution are added. The mixture is kept stirred at 20-25°C for approximately
20 min and then allowed to separate by settling. The lower organic phase comprising the
product is withdrawn. The organic phase comprising the product is again charged to the
reactor. 100 ml of demineraiized water are added. The mixture is kept stirred at 20-25°C for
approximately 20 min and then allowed to separate by settling. The lower organic phase
comprising the product is withdrawn. The organic phase comprising the product is again
charged to the reactor. 100 ml of isopropanol are added.
Distillation is carried out (35 + 5°C in the jacket) under a residual pressure of approximately
30 mbar until a residual volume of 100 ml is present in the reactor. The temperature is
adjusted.to 20°C and the mixture is left stirring at 20°C for 3 h. The reactor is rinsed and the
cake is washed twice with a total volume of 40 ml of isopropanol. The product is dried at
40°C under a vacuum of 30 mbar. Yield of isolated product: 60%.
Wittig reaction (Stage (ill)
581 g of phosphonium salt (1.2eq.), 350 g of the aldehyde from the preceding stage
(1.0 eq.) and 3500 ml of CHCI3 are charged to a 71 reactor (intense yellow-brown solution).
1110 ml of a 1N NaOH solution (1.2eq.) are added. The two-phase mixture is stirred
vigorously and the solution becomes pale yellow. It is kept at approximately 20°C. 3500 ml
of water are added and the mixture is stirred and separated by settling (pH of the aqueous
phase 13). A 2nd washing is carried out with 3500 ml of water; the pH is then 7. Separation
by settling is carried out and the yellow-orange organic phase is withdrawn (volume 4250 ml
comprising 346.0 g of Z and 136.7 g of E). The Z/E ratio is 72/28 and the Z+E yield with
respect to the aldehyde is 96.2%.
The solution is reintroduced into the reactor and then the CHCI3 is distilled off under vacuum
with a starting vacuum of 100 mbar and a final vacuum of 45 mbar flacket temperature
approximately 30°C). The mixture becomes syrupy. The vacuum is broken and 50 ml of
CHCI3 and 2500 ml of AcOiPr are added: a fluid solution is obtained (5250 ml). The
distillation is resumed at constant volume with addition of AcOiPr. Crystals (predominantly
of triphenyfphosphine oxide) are formed and are filtered off. The filtrate comprising the
expected product is retained for use in the following stage. Z/E ratio = 71/29. Z yield: 68.9%.
Deprotection in an acid medium (Stage (HP)
The solution from the preceding stage (3045.9 g of solution, i.e. 343.9 g of Z and 136.9 g of
E) is charged. 295.2 ml of a 12N HCI solution (4 eq., with respect to the product) are added.
The two-phase mixture changes from yellow to dark red. 1800 ml of water are added, the
mixture is stirred for 10min and separated by settling, and the rich aqueous phase is
withdrawn. 900 ml of water are added to the organic phase. The mixture is separated by
settling and the aqueous phase is withdrawn. 3714 g of orange aqueous phase are obtained
(Z/E ratio = 67/33). 2700 ml of AcOiPr are added and a 10N NaOH solution is run in slowly
until a pH of 10-11 is obtained. The mixture is separated by settling and the aqueous phase
is withdrawn. 2700 ml of water and 11 g of NaCI are added and the mixture is vigorously
stirred and then separated by settling. This whisking operation is repeated with 2700 ml of
water. A yellow organic phase is recovered (2760 g) Z/E ratio = 68/32. Yield: 35%.
Recrvstallization (Stage (iv))
5.27 g of the preceding product 50 ml of water, 50 ml of AcOiPr and 1.32 ml of 30% sodium
hydroxide solution are charged to a 250 mi three-necked flask. The mixture is stirred for
30min. It is separated by settling and the aqueous phase (pH = 10) is withdrawn. Two
whisking operations are carried out with water (50 mi). After the 2nd whisking operation, the
pH is 7. The organic phase is evaporated to dryness (40°C, vacuum of 60 mbar) and the
residue is dried in an oven (40°C). The solid (5.49 g) is taken up in 11.2 ml of MEC, and
1.00 ml of a 12N HCI solution {density =1.18) is added to the solution. A small amount of
product is allowed to slowly crystallize. 0.36 ml of water is added and a large part of the
crystallized product redissolves. 2.70 ml of MEC are then added and crystallization is again
allowed to take place. The mixture is stirred at ambient temperature for 5 days. The product
is obtained with a Z/E ratio = 93/07. Z yield: 45%.
Example 1a: Preparation of the hydrochloride of the compound (II)
Wittiq reaction (Stage (»))
44.8 g of phosphonium salt (1.2 eq.), 27 g of the aldehyde from the preceding stage
(1.0 eq.) and 270 ml of CHCI3 are charged to a 500 ml reactor (intense yellow-brown
solution). 85.6 mi of a 1N NaOH solution (1.2eq.) are added. The two-phase mixture is
stirred vigorously and the solution becomes pale yellow. It is maintained at approximately
20°C for approximately 4 h. 270 ml of water are added and the mixture is stirred and
separated by settling (pH of the aqueous phase 13). A 2nd washing operation is carried out
with 270 ml of water; the pH is then 7. The mixture is separated by settling and the yellow-
orange organic phase (weight 470.4 g, comprising 26.7 g of Z and 11.2 g of E) is withdrawn.
The Z/E ratio is 70/30, the Z+E ratio with respect to the aldehyde is 98% and the Z yield
with respect to the aldehyde is 69.0%.
The solution is reintroduced into the reactor and then a change in solvent to isopropyl
acetate is carried out under reduced pressure (45 to 100 mbar at 30°C approximately). At
the end of the operation, the residual volume is adjusted to 203 ml. Crystals are formed,
which crystals are filtered off and washed with isopropyl acetate. The filtrate, comprising the
reaction product, is used as is in the following stage. Z/E ratio = 70/30. Z yield: 69.0%.
Deprotection in acidic medium (Stage (iii)
The solution from the preceding stage (248.0 g of solution, i.e. 26.7 g of Z and 11.2 g of E)
is charged to a 500 ml reactor. 23.3 ml of a 12N HCI solution (4 eq. with respect to the
product) are added. The two-phase mixture changes from yellow to dark red. The mixture is
kept stirred at 20°C for approximately 5 h. 137 ml of water are added, the mixture is stirred
for 10 min and separated by settling, and the rich aqueous phase is withdrawn. 69 ml of
water are added to the organic phase. The mixture is separated by settling and the aqueous
phase is withdrawn. 283.6 g of orange aqueous phase are obtained (Z/E ratio = 66/34).
206 ml of AcOiPr are added and a 10N NaOH solution is slowly run in until a pH of 10-11 is
obtained. The mixture is separated by settling and the aqueous phase is withdrawn. 206 ml
of water and 2.1 g of NaCl are added and the mixture is vigorously stirred and then
separated by settling. This operation is repeated a second time. A yellow organic phase is
recovered and is brought to dryness (35.0 g, Z/E ratio = 66/34). This residue is taken up in
108.3 g of MEC. A solution is obtained. 5.82 ml of 12N HCI and 275 mi of water are
successively added. Initiation is subsequently carried out by the addition of 75 mg of pure Z
isomer. The mixture is kept stirred at 20°C for 24 h and then the slurry obtained is filtered.
The cake is pulled as dry as possible and then dried in an oven (50°C, 60 mbar). 7.15 g of a
fine beige powder are thus obtained: Z yield: 31.5%, Z/E ratio = 95.9/4.1.
Recrvstallization (Stage (iv)
488 mg of compound (I) (Z/E = 93.5/6.5), 0.115 ml of water and 268 ml of acetonitrile are
charged to a 5 ml round-bottomed flask. The mixture is heated to 35°C, stirred until a
solution is obtained and then cooled to 20°C. Initiation is carried out at this temperature with
3 mg of the pure Z isomer. The mixture is kept stirred for 30 min and then 3.44 ml of
acetonitrile are run in over approximately 2 h. The mixture is subsequently kept stirred at
20°C for 18 h and filtered. The cake obtained is dried in an oven (50°C, 60 mbar). 367 mg of
the expected product are thus obtained with a Z/E ratio of 99.65/0.35, i.e. a yield of 80%.
CLAIMS
1. Process for the preparation of a combretastatin derivative of formula (I) or (II):
A" denoting the anion associated with an acid AH, comprising the following stages:
• triaryl(3,4,5-trimethoxybenzy!)phosphonium halide P3
in which Ar denotes an aryl group chosen from phenyl or thienyl, optionally substituted
by a (C1-C4)alkyl, (C1-C4)alkoxy or halogen group, is reacted, in the presence of a base,
with:
- P2 of formula:
in which R and R' represent:
o each a (C1-C4)alkyl group;
o or else R represents a phenyl group optionally substituted by a (C1-C4)alkoxy
group and R' represents a hydrogen atom;
o or else R and R' form, together with the carbon atom to which they are connected,
a {C3-C7)cycloalkyl group;
- or else P'2 of formula:
in which PG1 represents a protective group for the alcohol functional group,
X representing boc, Fmoc or CBZ,
so as to respectively obtain the compound P4 or P'4:
• then, during a deprotection stage in the presence of an acid and/or of a base, the
compound of formula P4 or P'4 results, after an optional purification stage, in the
compound of formula (I) or (II).
2. Process according to Claim 1, in which R and R' both represent a methyl group or form,
together with the carbon atom to which they are connected, the cyclohexyl group.
3. Process according to Claim 1 or 2, in which X represents boc.
4. Process according to Claim 1 to Claim 3, in which PG-, represents one of the following
protective groups: THP (tetrahydropyran), MEM (methoxyethoxymethyl), boc, trityl or
acetyl (Ac).
5. Process according to Claim 1 to Claim 4, in which Ar represents the phenyl or thienyl
group, optionally substituted by a (C1-C4)alkyl or (C1-C4)alkoxy group.
6. Process according to one of Claims 1 to 5, in which A" denotes CI-.
7. Compound of formula P2:
in which R and R' represent:
o each a (C1-C4)alkyl group;
o or else R represents a phenyl group optionally substituted by a (C1-C4)alkoxy
group and R' represents a hydrogen atom;
o or else R and R' form, together with the carbon atom to which they are connected,
a (C3-C7)cycloalkyl group;
and X represents boc, Fmoc or CBZ.
8. Compound according to Claim 7, in which X represents boc.
9. Compound according to Claim 8, in which R and R' both represent a methyi group or
else R and R' form, together with the carbon atom to which they are connected, the
cyclohexyl group.
10. Compound of formula P'2:
in which PG1 represents a protective group for the alcohol functional group and X
represents boc, Fmoc or CBZ.
11. Compound according to Claim 10, in which PG1 represents THP (tetrahydropyran),
MEM (methoxyethoxymethyl), boc, trityl or acetyl (Ac).
12. Use of a compound according to Claim 7 to Claim 11 as intermediate in the preparation
of a compound of formula (I) or (II) as defined in Claim 1.
ABSTRACT
The invention relates to a
method for preparing a combretastatin
derivative (I) or (II), said method including
the following steps: triaryl(3,4,5-
trimethoxybenzyl)phosphonium halide P3
(III), wherein Ar denotes an aryl group
selected from among phenyl or thienyl, is
reacted with P2 having formula (IV) or P'2
having formula (V) so as to respectively
obtain the compound P4 or P'4, which have
formulas (VI) and (VII), respectively; then,
during a step for deprotection in the presence
of an acid and/or a base, the compound
having P4 or P'4 leads, after an optional
purification step, to the compound having
formula (I) or (II).
| # | Name | Date |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-TRANSLATED COPY OF PRIORITY DOCUMENT.pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 2 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-PCT SEARCH REPORT & OTHERS.pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 3 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-INTERNATIONAL PUBLICATION.pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 4 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-GPA.pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 5 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-FORM-5.pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 6 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-FORM-3.pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 7 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-FORM-2.pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 8 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-FORM-1.pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 9 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-DESCRIPTION (COMPLETE).pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 10 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 11 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-CLAIMS.pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 12 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-ASSIGNMENT.pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 13 | 1384-kolnp-2012-(6-6-2012)-ABSTRACT.pdf | 2012-09-19 |
| 14 | 1384-KOLNP-2012-(04-12-2012)-CORRESPONDENCE.pdf | 2012-12-04 |
| 15 | 1384-KOLNP-2012-(04-12-2012)-ANNEXURE TO FORM 3.pdf | 2012-12-04 |