Specification
AN ELECTRIC ARC EXTINCTION CHAMBER
Background of the invention
The invention relates to the field of chambers and
5 devices for extinguishing electric arcs.
Circuit breaker devices for low voltages
(U_AC~lOOO volts (V) and U DC~l500V), generally enable an
electric arc to be extinguished in air. The advantage of
this technique compared with extinguishing the arc in a
10 vacuum, in sulfur hexafluoride (SF6), or in oil, or indeed
compared with devices making use of an insulated gate
bipolar transistor (IGBT), lies in being simple to
fabricate and use, and consequently in being of low cost.
Breaking current on a direct current (DC)
15 electricity network necessarily involves generating a
back electromotive force (emf) of potential that is
greater than the potential of the source to be
interrupted. This is the major difficulty for breaking
DC. In the context of techniques for breaking in air,
20 the electric arc generated when opening the switch in air
is used as means for generating a back emf.
The main techniques of breaking in air are discussed
below.
The arc lengthening technique serves to lengthen and
25 thus cool the arc while opening the switch.
Nevertheless, this principle can be found to have poor
performance on overload.
The technique of lengthening and splitting the arc
combines lengthening the arc with splitting it in an
30 extinction chamber. Depending on the current to be
broken, it is possible that splitting might not come into
effect and there can exist critical levels of current for
which the arc stagnates at the inlet to the chamber.
This principle has the advantage of behaving well on
35 overload since the splitter plates support the arc and
enable it to be cooled effectively.
il
t[
~ i
i il
2
The technique of lengthening by magnetic blowout
uses a permanent magnet that tends to blow the arc out
magnetically. Such magnetic blowout lengthens the arc to
a great extent and cools it effectively. Nevertheless,
5 this extinction principle can be limited at high currents
since the cooling of the arc can be degraded as a result
of lengthening being less effective at such a level of
current.
Furthermore, and by way of example, extinction can
10 be made more difficult in the field of photovoltaic (PV)
installations because the panels being used deliver
voltages that increase from year to year in order to
reduce the costs of such installations. In the content
of such applications, it is known to connect a plurality
15 of switches in series in order to increase the breaking
capacity of the resulting device. Nevertheless, that
solution is not entirely satisfactory.
Other applications, e.g. in the railway field, can
also require the use of devices having considerable
20 breaking capacity on a DC network so as to enable
overload voltages to be broken.
It is thus desirable to improve existing electric
arc extinction devices by improving their arc extinction
capacity. It is also desirable to obtain circuit breaker
25 devices that can be used for splitting an electric arc
generated after passing a direct current or an
alternating current between electrical contacts.
There thus exists a need to have novel extinction
chambers and novel breaker devices presenting improved
30 circuit-breaking capacity.
There also exists a need to have novel breaker
devices suitable for facilitating penetration of an
electric arc into the depth of the extinction chamber.
There also exists a need to have novel breaker
35 devices and novel extinction chambers capable of
splitting an electric arc after a direct current or an
3
alternating current has been flowing between electrical
contacts.
Object and summary of the invention
5 To this end, in a first aspect, the invention
provides an electric arc extinction chamber comprising:
· a stack of electric arc splitter plates, the
splitter plates defining an inlet of the extinction
chamber that is to be present facing electric contacts,
10 and a back of the extinction chamber; and
· at least one permanent magnet present inside the
extinction chamber in a central zone in the width
direction of the extinction chamber and beside .its back,
the magnet presenting magnetization having a non-zero
15 component along an axis extending between the .inlet and
the back of the extinction chamber.
The central zone in the width direction of the
extinction chamber corresponds to the zone of the .inside
of the extinction chamber defined by planes of equation
20 xa = 0.25L and xb = 0. 75L, where L designates the width of
the extinction chamber and where xa and xb are measured
along the width of the extinction chamber, taking one of
the ends of the splitter plates as the origin.
The magnet .is also situated beside the back of the
25 extinction chamber, i.e. the magnet is closer to the back
of the extinction chamber than to the inlet of the
extinction chamber, and the magnet generates a magnetic
field of intensity that increases on going from the inlet
towards the back of the extinction chamber.
30 The .invention advantageously makes .it possible to
provide extinction chambers presenting improved
extinction capacity.
In an embodiment, the magnet may be held in an
electrically insulated magnet support.
35 In an embodiment, the magnet support may be
assembled by engagement with one or more splitter plates.
'~ '
4
Such a characteristic is advantageous since it makes
it possible to place the magnet as close as possible to
the back of the extinction chamber and for the magnet to
have a stationary position relative to the splitter
5 plates.
In an embodiment, the extinction chamber may further
include a flux channeling element present inside the
extinction chamber.
The flux channeling element is constituted at least
10 in part by a magnetic part extending towards the inlet of
the extinction chamber, e.g. a part of elongate shape.
15
The presence of a flux channeling element is
advantageous since it contributes to "stretching'' a
maximum of the magnetic field line generated by the
magnet_· towards the inlet of the extinction chamber; .. The
flux channeling element thus serves to further improve
the attraction of an electric arc towards the back of the
extinction chamber.
The flux channeling element may be placed facing the
20 magnet.
The flux channeling element may be held in the
magnet support, and for example it may be in contact with
the magnet. Nevertheless, as can be seen from the
description below, such a configuration is not essential.
25 Preferably, the extinction chamber is symmetrical
about a plane of equation x = 0.5L, where L designates
the width of the extinction chamber and where x is
measured along the width L of the extinction chamber,
taking one of the ends of the splitter plates as the
30 origin.
35
Such a configuration is advantageous since it makes
it possible to have an extinction chamber of extinction
capacity that is unaffected by the direction in which the
electric arc moves when the contacts open or by the
polarity with which the breaker device is connected.
i
I
I
i
I I
I
I i
li
5
This configuration is particularly advantageous with
DC because it is invariant relative to the polarity with
which the breaker device is connected.
In an embodiment, the height of the magnet may be
5 greater than or equal to half the height of the stack of
splitter plates. Under such circumstances, the height of
the magnet may be less than, or equal to, or greater than
the height of the stack of splitter plates. In a
variant, the height of the magnet may be less than half
10 the height of the stack of splitter plates.
In an embodiment, a single magnet may be present
inside the extinction chamber.
In a variant, a plurality of permanent magnets may
be present inside the extinction chamber, at least one
15 magnet of said plnrality of magnets being' pres·ent .in· the
central zone in the width direction of the extinction
chamber and beside its back. Under such circumstances,
the magnets of this plurality of magnets may optionally
be in contact with one another. The magnets of the
20 plurality of magnets may have the same magnetization
direction, but that is not essential. In an embodiment,
the majority, or even all, of the magnets in this
plurality of magnets may be present in the central zone
in the width direction of the extinction chamber and
25 beside its back.
30
35
In an embodiment, the extinction chamber may include
one or more electrically insulating electric arc guide
cheeks, the guide cheeks being situated at the inlet of
the extinction chamber and covering the ends of the
splitter plates in full or in part.
The presence of one or more guide cheeks is
advantageous insofar as they serve to prevent the arc
from attaching to the ends of the splitter plates,
thereby further improving extinction performance by
increasing the lengthening of the arc and thus the
voltage of the arc.
6
In an embodiment, the guide cheek(s) may be secured
to the magnet support, and for example they may be made
integrally therewith.
The pre~ent invention also provides a circuit
5 breaker device comprising:
an extinction chamber as defined above; and
a contact zone in which there are present at least
one stationary contact and at least one movable contact
that is movable relative to the stationary contact, the
10 contacts being.suitable for being_ put into contact with
each other and for being separated from each other, the
stationary contact being present facing the inlet of the
extinction chamber.
In an embodiment, the movable contact may be
15 conf·igured to: move· in rotation about an axis of rotation
while the contacts are being separated.
In an embodiment, the device may further include an
arcing horn present facing the stationary contact, the
width of the arcing horn being greater than the width of
20 the stationary contact.
Because of the presence of the permanent magnet in
the extinction chamber, an arc generated between the
contacts tends to have a non-zero movement component
along the width of the extinction chamber. Thus, e.g.
25 when the movable contact is moved in rotation about an
axis of rotation while the contacts are separating, the
arc that is generated tends to be deflected with a nonzero
component along the axis of rotation. It is thus
important for the arcing horn to be wider than the
30
35
stationary contact so that while the arc is being
deflected along the width of the extinction chamber, it
can become "attached" to the arcing horn. Using an
arcing horn can advantageously help in splitting the
electric arc by facilitating entry of the arc into the
extinction chamber. Specifically, the electric arc
generated between the contacts under such circumstances
tends to move from the stationary contact towards the
7
arcing horn and thus to come closer to the back of the
extinction chamber. Another advantage associated with
using an arcing horn is reducing the erosion of the
stationary contact due to the arc as a result of limited
5 contact between the arc and the stationary contact.
In an embodiment, the height of the arcing horn may
be greater than or equal to the height of the stationary
contact.
In an embodiment, the movable contact may be
10 configured to move in rotation about an axis of rotation
when the contacts are being separated, and a flux
channeling element may be present inside the extinction
chamber, the flux channeling element having a face
situated beside the contact zone that, when the flux
15 channeling ·element ic observed in ·a. plane· ·perpendicular
to the axis of rotation, presents the same shape as the
path followed by the movable contact during separation of
the contacts.
Such a configuration is advantageous since in makes
20 it possible to conserve a constant distance between the
flux channeling element and the movable contact while the
contacts are separating, thereby further improving the
attraction of the arc into the extinction chamber.
In an embodiment, the device may further include a
25 flux channeling element present inside the extinction
chamber, at least a portion of the flux channeling
element being constituted by an arc switching element
present facing the stationary contact, the width of the
arc switching element being greater than the width of the
30 stationary contact.
35
In an embodiment, the flux channeling element may
include an arc switching element together with an
additional flux channeling element present in an
electrically insulating channeling element support.
Such configurations are advantageous since they make
it possible to have simultaneously the effect of magnetic
field lines generated by the magnet being "stretched''
8
t·owards the inlet of the extinction chamber and
assistance in causing the arc to enter into the
extinction chamber because of using the arc switching
element.
5 The device of the invention makes it possible to
10
15
extinguish an electric arc generated after passing DC or
an alternating current (AC) between the contacts.
Brief description of the drawings
Other characteristics and advantages of the:
invention appear from the following description of
particular embodiments of the invention given as nonlimiting
examples and with reference to the accompanying
drawings, in which:
··Figure 1· isc:.iln exploded view .of•·an· arc extinction
chamber of the invention;
· Figure 2 shows the Figure 1 extinction chamber in
the assembled state;
· Figure 3 is a section view of the extinction
20 chamber of Figures 1 and 2, perpendicular on a plane to
the height of the stack of splitter plates;
· Figure 4 shows a circuit breaker device of the
invention;--
· Figure 5 is a two-dimensional (2D) view of the
25 magnetic field lines created by the magnets in t.he
extinction chamber of Figures 1 to 3;
· Figures 6A and 6B show variant embodiments of
extinction chambers of the invention;
· Figures 7A to 70 show the use of an arcing horn in
30 a breaker device of the invention; and
· Figures SA and 8B show variant embodiments of
extinction chambers including a two-part flux channeling
element.
35 Detailed description of embodiments
Figure 1 is an exploded view of an arc extinction
chamber l of the invention. The extinction chamber l
9
comprises a stack of electric arc splitter plates 2
mounted on a plate support 3. Mounting splitter plates 2
on the plate support 3 makes it possible to form an
extinction chamber 1 that is rigid. The splitter plates
5 2 are made of mild steel, for example. By way of
example, the plate support 3 may be made of vulcanized
card. In a variant, the splitter plates 2 may be mounted
directly on the box constituting the outer housing of the
circuit breaker device. The extinction chamber 1 shown
10 in Figure 1. has a plurality of stacked splitter plates 2,
e.g. at least three stacked splitter plates 2, e.g. at
least five stacked splitter plates 2. The height h of
the. stack of splitter plates 2 corresponds to the
distance between the two splitter plates that are the
15 furthest apart. In the example shown, the· height•h of
the stack of splitter plates 2 is measured
perpendicularly to the splitter plates 2. The extinction
chamber 1 has an inlet 10 and a back 11 situated remote
from the inlet defined by the splitter plates 2. In
20 addition to the splitter plates 2, a permanent magnet 5
is present inside the extinction chamber 1. By way of
example, the magnet 5 is made of NdFeB. As shown, the
magnet 5 is present in an electrically insulating magnet
support 7 that is present inside the extinction chamber
25 1. The magnet 5 may be in the form of a bar, as shown in
Figure 1. By way of example, the bar may have a crosssection
that is rectangular, square, or circular. As
shown, the magnet 5 does not extend along the planes in
which the splitter plates 2 extend, but along the height
30 h of the stack of splitter plates 2. In the example
shown, the magnet 5 extends along a height ha, as measured
along the height g of the stack of splitter plates 2,
35
that is greater than or equal to 50% of the height h of
the stack of splitter plates 2. By way of example, the
height ha of the magnet 5 is greater than or equal to 75%
of the height g of the stack of splitter plates, the
height ha of the magnet 5 being substantially equal to the
,,
:-!
10
height .g of the stack of splitter plates, for example.
Nevertheless, the height of the magnet is not limited to
the configuration shown in Figure 1. Specifically, the
magnet may present a height that is greater than the
5 height of the stack of splitter plates. In a variant,
the magnet may present a height that is less than the
height of the stack of splitter plates. For example, the
magnet may present a height that is less than half the
height of the stack of splitter plates, and under such
10 circumstances the magnet may be p~esent solely in the
bottom portion of the extinction chamber.
By way of example, and as shown, a single magnet 5
is present inside the extinction chamber 1, however it
would not go beyond the ambit of the invention for a
15 plurality of magnets to be present inside the·extinction
chamber 1.
By way of example, the magnet support 7 is made of
plastics material. As shown, a flux channeling element 6
is placed in contact with the magnet 5 and is likewise
20 housed in the magnet support 7. The magnet 5 and the
flux channeling element 6 are electrically insulated by
25
30
the magnet support 7. By way of example, the flux
channeling element 6 is made of mild steel. The flux
channeling element may optionally have a laminated
structure. The magnet support 7 includes engagement
means 9, e.g. in the form of notches, that are to cooperate
by engaging some or all of the splitter plates 2.
The engagement of the magnet support 7 with the splitter
plates 2 serves to hold the magnet 5 stationary relative
to the splitter plates 2.
Once the magnet support 7 is fastened to the
splitter plates 2 via the engagement means 9, the magnet
5 is present inside the extinction chamber 1 beside the
back of the extinction chamber 1 and in its central zone
35 Zc in the width direction of the extinction chamber 1, as
shown in Figure 3. Figure 3 is a section view of the
exb.nction chamber of Figures 1 and 2 on a plane
I
.I il
H
11
perpendicular to the height of the stack of splitter
plates 2. As shown, the splitter plates 2 are V-shaped
when observed in a direction perpendicular to the planes
in which they extend. In a variant, the splitter plates
5 may be of some other shape, such as a U-shape, when
observed in a direction perpendicular to the planes in
which they extend. Figure 3 marks the depth E of the
extinction chamber 1 which corresponds to the distance
between the inlet 10 of the extinction chamber 1 and the
10 back 11 of the extinction chamber 1,· as measured -·
perpendicularly to the height ~ of the stack of splitter
plates 2. There can also be seen the width L of the
extinction chamber 1, where the width L is measured
perpendicularly to the height ~ of the stack of splitter
15 ·plates 2 and···perpr~nd:i.cula:cly ta the depth·· E of .cthe· :. ·
extinction chamber 1. Unless specified to the contrary,
the width L of the extinction chamber 1 corresponds to
the inside width of the extinction chamber as measured
between the ends 2a and 2b of the splitter plates 2. The
20 magnetization M of the magnet 5 (represented by arrow 15
in Figures 1 and 3) presents a non-zero component along
an axis Y extending between the inlet 10 and the back 11
of the extinction chamber (also referred to as the depth
axis Y of the extinction chamber 1). In particular, the
25
30
magnetization M may lie in the planes in which the
splitter plates 2 extend. The magnetization M may be
directed substantially solely along the depth axis Y of
the extinction chamber 1. The magnetization M is shown
as being directed towards the inlet 10 of the extinction
chamber 1, however it would not go beyond the ambit of
the invention for the magnetization to be directed
towards the back 11 of the extinction chamber 1. As
shown, the magnet 5 is present in a central zone Zc in the
width direction of the extinction chamber 1. In other
35 words, the magnet 5 is present in a zone defined by
planes Pa and P0 having respective equations xa = 0.25L
and xb = 0.75L, where Lis the width of the extinction
12
chamber 1 and where xa and xb are measured a~ong the width
L of the extinction chambe.r 1, taking one of the ends 2a
or 2b of the splitter plates 2 as the origin. By way of
example, the magnet may be present in a zone defined by
5 planes Pa and Pb having respective equations xa = 0.40L
and xb = 0. 60L.
In addition, the magnet 5 is situated beside the
back 11 of the extinction chamber, i.e. it is closer to
the back 11 of the extinction chamber 1 than is the inlet
10. 10 of the extinction chamber 1 .· In other words, the
magnet 5 is present in a zone defined by planes P'a and
P'b having respective equations Ya = 0.5p and Yb = p,
where E designates the depth of the extinction chamber 1
and where Ya and Yb are measured along the depth of the
15 extinction chambe:r•. 1. and take· one.:· of the ends •2a: ro face (F) situated besi•dsr:·:the t:oi:1tacb
zone (21) that, when the flux channeling element (6; 80)
is observed in a plane perpendicular to the axis of
rotation, presents the same shape as the path (C)
followed by the movable contact (22) during separation of
20 the contacts (22; 25).
25
30
14. A device (20). according to any one of claims 10 to
13, characterized in that it further includes a flux
ch~nneling element (80) present inside the extinction
chamber ( 1) •
element ( 80)
element ( 82)
the width L8
greater than
at least a portion of the flux channeling
being constituted by an arc switching
present facing the stationary contact (25),
of the arc switching element (82) being
the width Lt of the stationary contact (25).
15. A device (20) according to claim 14, characterized in
that the flux channeling element (80) includes an arc
switching element (82) together with an additional flux
channeling element (81) present in an electrically
35 insulating channeling element support (70).