Abstract: The present invention is in relation to three dimensional powder printing. The invention provides a binder system for powder printing and method of printing using the system.
Claims:1. A polymerisable binder system for 3D powder printing; said system comprising –
a) aqueous solution of acrylamide monomer and accelerator; and
b) initiator, wherein the initiator is mixed with powder.
2. The polymerisable binder system as claimed in claim 1, wherein the accelerator is
selected from a group comprising N,N,N’,N’-tetramethylethane- 1,2-diamine (TMEDA or
TEMED), triethylenediamine (TEDA), tetrakis(hydroxymethyl)phosphonium chloride
(THPC) and the like.
3. The polymerisable binder system as claimed in claim 1, wherein the initiator is selected
from a group comprising ammonium persulphate, benzoyl peroxide, potassium
persulphate, sodium persulphate, azobisisobutyronitrile and the like.
4. The polymerisable binder system as claimed in claim 1, wherein the solution comprises
acrylamide monomer ranging from about 20% wt/vol to about 25% wt/vol; preferably
about 22% wt/vol added with accelerator ranging from about 0.2% to about 0.4%
preferably 0.3% vol/vol; the initiator concentration ranging from 2% wt/wt to about
8%wt/wt.
5. The polymerisable binder system as claimed in claim 1, wherein the binder static and
dynamic viscosity is ranging between 10mPa.s to about 20mPa.s and surface tension is
about 56 mN/m.
6. A system for three dimensional printing, said system comprising aqueous solution of
acrylamide monomer, N,N,N’,N’-tetramethylethane- 1,2-diamine, ammonium persulphate
and powder to be printed.
7. The system as claimed in claim 6, wherein the powder is selected from a group of
materials comprising alloys of metal, ceramic and polymers.
21
8. A method of preparation of polymerisable binder system for powder printing of claim 1,
said method comprising acts of;
a) preparing aqueous solution of monomer of acrylamide;
b) adding accelerator to the solution to form a homogeneous solution; and
c) mixing initiator with powder to be printed to obtain polymerisable binder system for
powder printing.
9. The method as claimed in claim 8, wherein the mixing is done in a planetary ball mill at
a speed of about 200 rpm to about 300 rpm for a period ranging from about 15min to
about 30min.
10. A method of powder printing, said method comprising acts of
a) mixing initiator with powder to be printed to form a mixture; and
b) contacting the mixture with aqueous solution of acrylamide monomer and accelerator
for powder printing.
11. The method of powder printing as claimed in claim 10, wherein the printing is through
inkjet powder printing. , Description:TECHNICAL FIELD:
The present invention is in relation to three dimensional powder printing. The invention provides
a methodology to formulate a novel binder system for 3D powder printing of a range of
materials. In particular, this methodology involves the use of monomer solution of acrylamide,
other components of the binder system, i.e. accelerator and an initiator to be mixed with the
powder to be printed. The system allows in-situ polymerization to facilitate intense physico-
chemical binding in the powder bed during the printing of objects. The printing process is
environment friendly as it involves aqueous medium and cost-effective to develop three
dimensional printed constructs with enhanced strength.
BACKGROUND:
The osseointegration of implantable biomaterials depends on the tailored porous architecture to
promote biocompatibility (angiogenesis, tissue in-growth) and bone mimicking physical
properties (elastic modulus, strength). To address such twin requirements, 3D powder printing,
an ambient temperature additive manufacturing method is successively employed to incorporate
designed volume fraction of porosities in scaffolds/implants. This technology relies on binder-
powder interaction during printing, wherein the powder physically gets adhered with adhesive
binder layer by layer to yield the full 3D construct. In general, the binders are powder chemistry
specific and the employability is limited towards the spectrum of FDA approved powder
materials.
The three dimensional printing is widely used in the medical field to develop patient-specific
three dimensional complex implants for tissue engineering applications with tailored mechanical
3
properties. Titanium alloy, commonly known as Ti-6Al- 4V is one of the clinically accepted and
widely used biomaterial in bone tissue engineering as well as limb salvage applications due to its
higher strength to weight ratio and biocompatibility. The most sensitive body implants for
example, total hip system, prosthetic cardiac valves, U shape inter laminar stabilization device
implantable in spine, locking bone plates, screws and the like are commercially manufactured
and used according to the specifications. Similarly, partially magnesia stabilized zirconia, porous
HDPE are other internationally approved biomaterials for surgical implants.
Additive manufacturing technique, commonly known as three dimensional printing is widely
used over conventional manufacturing methods to create aforesaid objects. It is well known that
layers of materials are deposited to develop a three dimensional object in the aforesaid process.
Although monolithic metallic implants of titanium and its alloys, stainless steel, cobalt-
chromium are frequently used in orthopedic and arthroplastic surgeries, porous designs are
necessary to avoid the failure due to stress shielding effect and to enhance the cell-material
interaction and bone ingrowth. It is to be noted that by controlling the porosity distribution and
architecture, mechanical properties of the implants can be tailored for the tissue-specific
applications. In general, interconnected pores of larger than 400 µm are found to be suitable for
vascularization, while the minimum pore size for osteogenesis is 100 µm. In this context,
interconnected pores facilitate the transportation of nutrients to and metabolic wastes from cells.
Additive manufacturing has multifaceted advantages over the conventional manufacturing
technologies. The patient-specificity and the addition of materials in contrast to conventional
machining are the major advantages. In addition, the manufacturing of complex shapes,
including intricate interior features added with the scope to incorporate biomedically relevant
porous architectures to match the elastic modulus with the host tissues can be achieved through
4
additive manufacturing. 3D powder printing is superior to the high energy laser or electron beam
based additive manufacturing as it can print ceramics and composite materials. The spine of 3D
powder printing is based on the development of powder-specific binder and tailoring post-
printing methodology.
However, the major limitation of 3D powder printing of biomaterials is the unavailability of
universal binder. The binder chemistry and properties need to be tuned for a given biomaterial.
The binder addition for three dimensional printing are used in two modes – indirect and direct.
The indirect mode involves the mixing of water soluble binder powder with the powder to be
printed and subsequently printing with distilled water. In contrast, direct mode involves the use
of a water soluble binder directly to print the scaffolds. The as-printed strength and print
resolution are limited in case of ‘indirect’ printing and the high viscosity of binder used in
‘direct’ mode of printing results in frequent clogging of micro-orifices of printhead.
This invention aims to provide a cost effective, ecofriendly novel system of a universal binder
for effective 3D powder printing of metal, ceramics and polymers that can be easily adopted for
printing three dimensional objects with high strength. The invention also aims to develop a
method of printing that desist the use of any high energy source like selective laser sintering
(SLS), electron beam melting (EBM) and the like.
STATEMENT OF INVENTION
A polymerisable binder system for 3D powder printing; said system comprising – a) aqueous
solution of acrylamide monomer and accelerator; and b) initiator, wherein the initiator is mixed
with powder; a system for three dimensional printing, said system comprising aqueous solution
of acrylamide monomer, N,N,N’,N’-tetramethylethane- 1,2-diamine, ammonium persulphate and
5
powder to be printed; a method of preparation of polymerisable binder system for powder
printing of present invention, said method comprising acts of;a) preparing aqueous solution of
monomer of acrylamide, b) adding accelerator to the solution to form a homogeneous solution,
and c) mixing initiator with powder to be printed to obtain polymerisable binder system for
powder printing and a method of powder printing, said method comprising acts of a) mixing
initiator with powder to be printed to form a mixture; and b) contacting the mixture with aqueous
solution of acrylamide monomer and accelerator for powder printing.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF FIGURES
The features of the present invention can be understood in detail with the aid of appended
figures. It is to be noted however, that the appended drawings illustrate only typical
embodiments of this invention and are therefore not to be considered limiting of its scope for the
invention.
Figure 1: Working principle of the binder system and the process methodology of 3D inkjet
powder printing. (a) powder containing APS (initiator); (b) aqueous binder comprising
acrylamide and TEMED; (c) binder shower from printhead according to ‘demand’of the CAD;
(d) binder droplet impact on powder bed and the polymerisation starts in the presence of
monomer solution, intiator and accelerator; (e) in-situ growth of viscous polyacrylamide chains
and inter-particles as well as inter-layers adhesion; (f) examples of as printed 3D bodies.
Figure 2: Macrostructures of as-printed and sintered prototypes/lab-scale test samples of metals
(Ti-6Al- 4V), ceramics (Mg-PSZ) and polymers (HDPE). (a) top: HDPE acetabular socket
prototype, middle: Ti-6Al- 4Vgreen cylinders, bottom: Mg-PSZ green cylinders; (b) sintered Ti-
6Al-4V cylinder; (c) Mg-PSZ acetabular socket (green and sintered)
6
Figure 3: (a) Constant static viscosity (independent of shear rate) indicating the nature of the binder
as Newtonian and (b) the range of the dynamic viscosity (10 – 20 mPa.s), showing the efficacy of
the binder as printable.
Figure 4: X-ray diffraction pattern of as received Ti-6Al- 4V powder and sintered scaffold
showing the presence of a-Ti and ß-Ti phases. Highest intensity peak in the starting powder is
contributed by (110) plane of ß-Ti. A shoulder peak right side of this peak corresponds to the
(101) plane of a-Ti at 2? value of 40°. In the sintered scaffold, the decrease in intensity of (110)
ß-Ti and hike in peak intensity of (101) plane of a-Ti is noticed
Figure 5: XRD pattern of Mg-PSZ (as received powder and sintered bodies). The high
temperature symmetric phase (tetragonal) is retained in room temperature even after sintering to
the presence of MgO as the partial stabiliser. (m – monoclinic, t – tetragonal).
Figure 6:. Compressive strength and modulus of both sintered Mg-PSZ and Ti-6Al- 4V
cylinders. This comparative representation of bar diagrams of compressive strength and modulus
of Ti-6Al- 4V and Mg-PSZ depict the reduction in strength and modulus (e.g. 110 GPa for
monolithic Ti) due to incorporation of microporosity in the structure. These microporosities get
incorporated in the 3D printed constructs during the process itself. This reduction in modulus
assists in avoiding ‘stress-shielding’ / ‘aseptic loosening’ of implants anchored with host bone in
vivo.
Figure 7: Overall low resolution X Ray scan (pixel size ~ 30-40 µm) of microporous acetabular
socket and femoral head prototypes (Mg-PSZ). (a) Front orthoslice (the tappering and the
interconnected porosity); (b) femoral ball head of Mg-PSZ; (c) front orthoslice of Mg-PSZ 3D
printed acetabular socket prototype; (d) low resolution overall scan of the acetabular prototype.
7
Figure 8: High resolution 3D reconstructed Micro-CT images of both as printed and printed-
sintered Ti-6Al- 4V and Mg-PSZ, to illustrate the effect of sintering in terms of reduction in
porosity and extent of pore-interconnectivity.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF INVENTION
The foregoing description of the embodiments of the invention has been presented for
the purpose of illustration. It is not intended to be exhaustive or to limit the invention to
the precise form disclosed as many modifications and variations are possible in light of
this disclosure for a person skilled in the art in view of the figures, description and
claims. It may further be noted that as used herein and in the appended claims, the
singular “a” “an” and “the” include plural reference unless the context clearly dictates
otherwise. Unless defined otherwise, all technical and scientific terms used herein have
the same meanings as commonly understood by person skilled in the art.
The present invention is in relation to a polymerisable binder system for 3D powder printing;
said system comprising –
a) aqueous solution of acrylamide monomer and accelerator; and
b) initiator, wherein the initiator is mixed with powder.
In an embodiment of the invention, the accelerator is selected from a group comprising
N,N,N’,N’-tetramethylethane- 1,2-diamine (TMEDA or TEMED), triethylenediamine (TEDA),
tetrakis(hydroxymethyl)phosphonium chloride (THPC) and the like.
In an embodiment of the invention, the initiator is selected from a group comprising ammonium
persulphate, benzoyl peroxide, potassium persulphate, sodium persulphate, azobisisobutyronitrile
and the like.
8
In another embodiment of the invention, the solution comprises acrylamide monomer ranging
from about 20% wt/vol to about 25% wt/vol; preferably about 22% wt/vol added with accelerator
ranging from about 0.2% to about 0.4% preferably 0.3% vol/vol; the initiator concentration
ranging from 2% wt/wt to about 8%wt/wt.
In still another embodiment of the invention, the binder static and dynamic viscosity is ranging
between 10mPa.s to about 20mPa.s and surface tension is about 56 mN/m.
The present invention is in relation to a system for three dimensional printing, said system
comprising aqueous solution of acrylamide monomer, N,N,N’,N’-tetramethylethane- 1,2-
diamine, ammonium persulphate and powder to be printed.
In another embodiment of the invention, the powder is selected from a group of materials
comprising alloys of metal, ceramic and polymers.
The present invention is also in relation to a method of preparation of polymerisable binder
system for powder printing of present invention, said method comprising acts of;
a) preparing aqueous solution of monomer of acrylamide;
b) adding accelerator to the solution to form a homogeneous solution; and
c) mixing initiator with powder to be printed to obtain polymerisable binder system for
powder printing.
In yet another embodiment of the invention, the mixing is done in a planetary ball mill at a
speed of about 200 rpm to about 300 rpm for a period ranging from about 15min to about 30min.
The present inventionis also in relation to a method of powder printing, said method comprising
acts of
9
a) mixing initiator with powder to be printed to form a mixture; and
b) contacting the mixture with aqueous solution of acrylamide monomer and accelerator
for powder printing.
In another embodiment of the invention, the printing is through inkjet powder printing.
An embodiment of the present invention provides a universal binder for three
dimensional powder printing to build 3D scaffolds of metal, ceramic, polymeric powders
with excellent print resolution and as printed strength. The system of the binder typically
comprises two parts- one part comprising aqueous solution of monomer of acrylamide and an
accelerator; the other part comprising initiator and powder that is to be printed.
An initiator is mixed with the powder, which is subsequently printed with a monomer solution
added with an accelerator. The polymer chains grow in the micro-area of droplet impact locally
and bind the powder particles intimately. Accordingly, the binding involves in situ room
temperature polymerization reaction in the powder bed itself. When the aqueous solution of
monomer of acrylamide and accelerator arrives in contact with the powder pre-mixed with the
initiator, the polymerisation initiates. Consequently, a viscous high molecular weight polymer
known as polyacrylamide or poly(2-propenamide) is synthesized in situ, in the micro-area of the
impact of the binder droplet in the powder bed. As a result, the powder particles get adhered
quickly with the polymer chains and gets hardened during drying (Figure 1).
As the monomer solution has low viscosity, issues relating to the printhead nozzle clogging does
not arise. The as-printed strength is appreciably high due to the intimate binding of the in situ
grown polymer chains and subsequent drying of the molecules along with the powder particles.
Typically, the binder system comprises aqueous solution of acrylamide monomer ranging from
about 20% wt/vol to about 25%wt/vol; preferably about 22% wt/vol; accelerator ranging from
10
about 0.2% to about 0.4% preferably 0.3%vol/vol; initiator ranging from 2% wt/wt to about
8%wt/wt of the printable powder. The initiator concentration will vary depending on the density,
as powder volume spreaded in each layer remains constant during printing, of which, weight can
vary as per the corresponding density.
The accelerator is selected from a group comprising N,N,N’,N’-tetramethylethane- 1,2-diamine
(TMEDA or TEMED), triethylenediamine (TEDA), tetrakis(hydroxymethyl)phosphonium
chloride (THPC) and the like and the initiator is chosen from a group of initiators for vinyl
polymerization, such as ammonium persulphate, benzoyl peroxide, potassium persulphate,
sodium persulohate, azobisisobutyronitrile and the like.
The binder preparation involves simple steps in two parts. In the first part, aqueous solution of
monomer of acrylamide as the base is prepared, accelerator is added and stirred to form a clear
solution. In the other part, initiator is mixed with the powder to be printed. The two parts of the
binder independently are extremely stable without any requirement of preservation and allow
three dimensional printing seamlessly. The three dimensional printing involving said system
relies on the principle of drop-on- demand (DOD), which involves the ejection of liquid binder
through a set of orifices, forming ink droplets.
Typically, the exemplified reaction of the present invention involves contacting N,N,N’,N’-
tetramethylethane-1,2- diamine with the initiator, ammonium persulphate. The ammonium
persulphate structure breaks down and gives rise to free radicals. Essentially, N,N,N’,N’-
tetramethylethane-1,2- diamine accelerates the formation of free radicals from persulfate. These
free radicals are extremely unstable and attack the double bond of acrylamide molecule and get
consumed by the molecule. After consuming the reactive electron from the free radical, the a -
center of the acrylamide monomer becomes unstable and extremely reactive. Thereafter, the
11
reactive molecules attack more vinyl sites of the monomer molecules one by one and add them in
the backbone. This continues as a chain reaction and the molecular weight as well as viscosity of
the chain continues to increase. As the system is inclusive of loose powder predominantly, they
get adhered quickly with the adhesive polymer and get bound.
The present disclosure demonstrates effective functionality of this binder in three classes of
biomaterials, metal (Ti-6Al- 4V), ceramic (Mg-PSZ) and HDPE (polymer).
A. Three dimensional printing and post processing-General procedure:
a) The pre-mixed powder (powder particle size in the range of 20 – 50 micron) is stacked in
the feed bed of the powder inkjet printer (Spectrum 510, Zcorp, USA) and the cartridge and the
printhead (HP™ no. 11 black printhead) are cleaned and filled with the binder. The saturation is
kept in the range of 100-150%. The x-y resolution of print is maintained at 600*540 dpi with z
resolution (single layer thickness) in the range of 80-100 µm. Cylindrical specimens having the
dimensions of (1: 1) height:diameter ratio are printed for Ti-6Al- 4V and Mg-PSZ.
The prototypes of human acetabular cup for total hip replacement are also printed with excellent
precision using HDPE and Mg-PSZ. Additionally, one human femoral ball head is also printed
using Mg-PSZ powder. The images of the as-printed bodies and sintered bodies are shown in
figure 2.
b) After printing, the print area is illuminated with an incandescent light bulb for 45 minutes
and then the excess supporting powder is roughly removed. The portable build plate along with
the powder covered as-printed bodies is taken out from printer and kept in an hot air oven at 70 –
75°C for further drying and hardening. The total setting time (stone hard) is observed to be 40
minutes to 1 hour. The setting time is identical for this binder as the reaction does not depend on
the powder chemistry.
12
After drying, the as-printed bodies appear to have sufficient handling strength, and the loose
powder is removed from the surface using a brush. To further enhance the final strength of the
as-printed bodies, high temperature heat treatment is often prioritized. For ceramics (Mg-PSZ in
this study), the as-printed bodies are sintered at 1450°C for 1 hour using 10°/min heating ramp.
In case of Ti-6Al- 4V, the first heating ramp (10°C/min) is limited up to 450°C and dwelled for 1
hour to remove the binder. The second heating ramp is started at the rate of 20°C/min, until it
reaches the final sintering temperature (1400°C). At 1400 °C, samples were kept for 2 hours and
furnace cooled.
B. Binder rheology, surface tension and pH
The flow behaviour of the binder is primarily governed by its static and dynamic viscosity,
which is characterized using a cone-plate viscometer (DHR3, TA instruments, USA). In static
viscosity measurement, the change in viscosity is monitored by changing the shear rate, while the
complex/dynamic viscosity is measured by varying the angular frequency. The static viscosity is
measured to be ~1.8 mPa.s, which is very less to be considered. Dynamic viscosity lies in the
range of 10 – 20 mPa.s and the prescribed value is below 30 mPa.s for best printability. These
values show clear indications of excellent binder physics under flow (Figure 3a and b).
The interfacial tension between liquid droplets and air, which is commonly known as surface
tension is measured using ‘pendant drop’ method in a contact angle goniometer (OCA 15EC,
Dataphysics®, Germany). The value is found to be ~56 mN/m. This value is less enough not to
form ligaments behind proceeding droplets and hence ensures good resolution.
The pH of the solution of acrylamide based binder lies in between 7.5 – 8 (little basic). This is
due to the presence of basic accelerator (TEMED) and such effect gets nullified after the
13
disintegration of TEMED during polymerization reaction in the powder bed. This pH value, in
turn, promotes the reaction, as the efficiency of reaction falls rapidly below pH 6.
C. Phase assemblage, mechanical and microstructural properties
Phase assemblage:
A diffractometer (X’ Pert Pro, PANalytical, Netherlands) is used to investigate the phase
assemblage in powder as well as in sintered scaffolds (both Mg-PSZ and Ti-6Al- 4V). For the
XRD (X-ray diffraction), samples are scanned for 2? in the range of 20° to 90° for Ti-6Al- 4V
and 20° to 70° with a scan rate of 0.06°/sec using Cu Ka radiation of wavelength 1.5418 Å.
Figure 4 represents the X-ray diffraction pattern of as received Ti-6Al- 4V powder and sintered
scaffold. In case of as-printed Ti-6Al- 4V, XRD pattern confirmed the presence of a-Ti (HCP) as
a predominant phase and metastable ß-Ti (BCC) as a minor phase due to the presence of ß
stabilizer (Vanadium). Importantly, no diffraction peak corresponding to oxide of Ti is found
within the detection limit, after sintering. An increase in intensity of diffraction peak
corresponding to (101) plane of a-Ti after sintering associated with a decreased intensity of
diffraction peak corresponding to (110) plane of ß-Ti. In the XRD pattern of Mg-PSZ,
monoclinic phases are predominant in the as received powder as expected. In contrast,
metastable tetragonal phases are observed in the sintered scaffolds due to the presence of the
magnesia as a partial stabiliser, which aids in retaining the high temperature phase (tetragonal) in
room temperature (Figure 5).
D. Mechanical properties:
Compressive stress – strain behaviours of the sintered cylinders of both Ti-6Al- 4V and Mg-PSZ
are measured in Universal Testing Machine (Zwick/Roell, USA) using 100 kN load cell with
crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/min. Compressive strength and modulus of the microporous sintered
14
Mg-PSZ cylinders (height ~ 13mm and diameter ~9 mm) are found to be in the order of 15
(±1.2) MPa and 6.6 (±0.9) GPa, respectively. On the other hand, compressive strength and
biomedically relevant modulus are found in the case of sintered Ti-6Al- 4V cylinders (both height
and diameter ~ 11 mm), where the values lie in the order of 222 (± 32) MPa and 4 (±0.3) GPa
respectively. The compressive strength and modulus of both sintered Mg-PSZ and Ti-6Al- 4V
cylinders are presented in Figure 6. This comparative representation of bar diagrams in figure 6
of compressive strength and modulus of Ti-6Al- 4V and Mg-PSZ depict the reduction in strength
and modulus (e.g. 110 GPa for monolithic Ti) due to incorporation of microporosity in the
structure. Also, a comparative analysis of mechanical properties of three dimensionally printed
object of present invention with the objects printed according to literature is provided in Table 1.
These microporosities get incorporated in the 3D printed constructs during the process itself.
This reduction in modulus assists in avoiding ‘stress-shielding’ / ‘aseptic loosening’ of implants
anchored with host bone in vivo.
Table 1: Comparative analysis of mechanical properties of three dimensionally printed
object of present invention with the objects printed according to literature.
Reported binders for
3D powder printing
of Ti and Ti6A14V
Sintering
temperature
(ºC)
Compression
Strength
(MPa)
Compressive
modulus (GPa)
Reference
Deionised water as
binder for Ti
premixed with PVA
powder
1300 107.2 0.86 Gagg et al. Materials
Science and
Engineering: C
2013;33(7):3858-3864.
Deionised water as
binder for Ti
premixed with PVA
powder
1350 455 13.2 Wiria et al.
Materials & Design
2010;31, Supplement
1(0):S101-S105
Deionised water as
binder fir Ti premixed
with PVA powder
1370 - 2.5 Hajje et al.
Journal of Materials
Science: Materials in
Medicine
2014;25(11):2471-
15
2480.
Deionised water as
binder for Ti
premixed with PVA
powder
1350 - 2.1 Maleksaeedi et al.
Procedia CIRP
2013;5(0):158-163
Aqueous
Maltodextrin solution
as binder for Ti-6A1-
4V powder
1400 200 4.0 Barui et al., Materials
Science and
Engineering: C, 70
(2017) 812-823
Novel in situ
polymerisable acrylic
binder for printable
biomaterials
1400 222.6 4.1 Present invention
E. Microstructural studies:
The finer scale 3D microstructure in terms of the internal porosity distributions in the as-printed
and sintered bodies of both Mg-PSZ and Ti-6Al- 4V are extensively studied using micro-
computed tomography (m-CT). The X-Ray scanning recipes for all components, including both
as-printed and sintered bodies, are shown in Table 2.
Table 2: X-Ray tomographic scan recipes for green and sintered cylinders and prototypes
Sample names X Ray
Energy (kV)
Power
(W)
Exposure
time (s)
Objectives
(X)
Pixel size
(µm)
Resolution
Ti-6Al- 4V as-printed
cylinder
120 10 2 4 3.15 High
Ti-6Al- 4V sintered
cylinder
140 10 2 4 3.18 High
Mg-PSZ as-printed
cylinder
140 10 2.5 4 4.3 High
Mg-PSZ sintered
cylinder
140 10 3.0 4 4.23 High
Mg-PSZ acetabular
socket (sintered)
140 10 7 0.39 38.32 Low
16
Mg-PSZ femoral head
(sintered)
140 10 7 0.39 29.8 Low
Figure 7 shows the overall low resolution X Ray scan (pixel size ~ 30-40 µm) of microporous
acetabular socket and femoral head prototypes (Mg-PSZ). High resolution scan (pixel size ~ 3-
4µm) of both as-printed and sintered Ti-6Al- 4V and Mg-PSZ cylinders were carried out to
critically quantify the volume fractions of material and pore phases as well as pore-
interconnectivity. Essentially, the single predominant color (green / blue) of a particular
parallelepiped pore phase in Figure 8 represents one single pore. Other colors, scattered
randomly as dots or small spheres, represent closed pores.
F. Experiment 1:
Method of preparation of the binder system for three dimensional printing.
22% (wt./vol.) aqueous solution of monomer of acrylamide is prepared as the base of the binder.
0.3% (vol./vol) N,N,N’,N’-tetramethylethane- 1,2-diamine is added and mixed by magnetic
stirring until a clear homogeneous solution is obtained. 2 -8% (wt./wt.) Ammonium persulphate
is mixed with the base powder (any powder to be printed) in a planetary ball mill at 300 rpm for
20 minutes. As Ammonium persulphate is extremely hygroscopic, attention is provided to keep
the pre-mixed powder in a tightly closed container and away from moisture.
Experiment 2: 3D powder printing of Mg-PSZ acetabular socket prototype:
a) Preparation of the powder:
500 gm spray dried Mg-PSZ powder is taken as the base material to be printed and 4% (wt/wt)
ammonium persulphate (APS) as the initiator is mixed in a planetary ball mill using agate jar and
agate balls. Ten batches of milling were carried out by taking 50 gm powder in each using 4:1
17
ball-powder ratio at 200 rpm for 20 minutes. The agate balls are separated and the powder is kept
in an airtight container as APS is extremely hygroscopic.
b) Preparation of binder:
The binder was prepared by dissolving 66 gm of acrylamide and 0.9 ml TEMED in 300 ml
distilled water (DI) under magnetic stirring for 15 minutes. The dissolution of acrylamide in
water is spontaneous and endothermic in nature. Once the entire acrylamide is dissolved, the
solution is filtered in Whatman 40 filter paper to ensure no presence of any solid particulate,
having the potential to clog the printhead micro-orifices (dia ~ 40-45 micron) during printing.
c) CAD modeling of acetabular socket:
A solid model of a standard acetabular socket is generated in a solid modeling software (viz.
Catia TM , Solidworks TM ) having the dimension of 56 mm and 32 mm as the OD and ID
respectively. The file is exported in *.stl format and fed in the slicing software (ZPrint TM ) which
subsequently sliced it in 260 layers keeping 0.1 mm layer thickness.
d) 3D powder printing of the Mg-PSZ acetabular socket prototype
The powder is stacked in the feed bed with sufficient height for the CAD (26 mm at least). The
cartridge is filled with binder and the ‘HP TM no. 11 black’ printhead is purged, cleaned and filled
with the binder. The binder line is ‘primed’ to remove existing air and the printhead is placed on
the septum firmly. The saturation is maintained at 150 % and the printing is carried out at 38°C
temperature (machine preset). After finishing the printing, the build area is illuminated with an
incandescent lamp (60-70°C) for ½ an hour and the loose powder is removed using a brush
superficially without touching the as-printed architecture. The portable build plate, containing
the powder covered architecture, is placed in a hot air oven at 70°C for 1 hour. After this, the
18
plate is taken out from oven and the loose powder is removed (‘depowdering’) using a
compressed air nozzle to reveal the geometry details intricately.
e). Post processing - high temperature heat treatment/sintering
The as printed acetabular socket is kept in an open air furnace (Carbolite TM ) and heated up to
1400°C using 10°C/min ramping and dwelled for 2 hours. The furnace is cooled normally and
the sintered prototype is taken out and the shrinkage is measured which was in the range of 20-
23%.
The present invention unveils a new horizon in 3D powder printing for various applications
including biomedical applications. The use of a universal binder satisfies several folds of
requirements. The system of the universal binder addresses the limitations of applicability of the
proprietary binder, which comes along with all commercial 3D powder printers. The binding
involves a room temperature polymerization reaction without any need of external energy
stimuli. The polymerization is rapid, a key requirement for 3D powder printing where the
viscous polymeric chains should form in between two layers pass. The polyacrylamide, formed
during 3D powder printing, is a biocompatible material with low setting time. Finally, the cost of
the chemicals is considerably less providing a economically viable, ecofriendly process and
product. This binder can be extensively used to fabricate patient specific implants for example
dental and orthopaedic implants in a cost-effective manner, thereby paving the way for
affordable healthcare.
The aforesaid description enables one to capture the nature of the invention. It is to be noted
however that the aforesaid description and the appended figures illustrate only a typical
19
embodiment of the invention and therefore not to be considered limiting of its scope for the
invention may admit other equally effective embodiments.
It is an object of the appended claims to cover all such variations and modifications that can
come within the true spirit and scope of the invention.
| # | Name | Date |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Form 5 [27-04-2017(online)].pdf | 2017-04-27 |
| 2 | Form 3 [27-04-2017(online)].pdf | 2017-04-27 |
| 3 | Form 18 [27-04-2017(online)].pdf_72.pdf | 2017-04-27 |
| 4 | Form 18 [27-04-2017(online)].pdf | 2017-04-27 |
| 5 | Form 1 [27-04-2017(online)].pdf | 2017-04-27 |
| 6 | Drawing [27-04-2017(online)].pdf | 2017-04-27 |
| 7 | Description(Complete) [27-04-2017(online)].pdf_71.pdf | 2017-04-27 |
| 8 | Description(Complete) [27-04-2017(online)].pdf | 2017-04-27 |
| 9 | PROOF OF RIGHT [09-06-2017(online)].pdf | 2017-06-09 |
| 10 | Form 26 [09-06-2017(online)].pdf | 2017-06-09 |
| 11 | Correspondence by Agent_Form 1_Power Of Attorney_14-06-2017.pdf | 2017-06-14 |
| 12 | 201741014912-FER.pdf | 2019-07-26 |
| 13 | 201741014912-OTHERS [04-09-2019(online)].pdf | 2019-09-04 |
| 14 | 201741014912-FORM 3 [04-09-2019(online)].pdf | 2019-09-04 |
| 15 | 201741014912-FER_SER_REPLY [04-09-2019(online)].pdf | 2019-09-04 |
| 16 | 201741014912-DRAWING [04-09-2019(online)].pdf | 2019-09-04 |
| 17 | 201741014912-CORRESPONDENCE [04-09-2019(online)].pdf | 2019-09-04 |
| 18 | 201741014912-CLAIMS [04-09-2019(online)].pdf | 2019-09-04 |
| 19 | 201741014912_Marked up Claims_Granted 326513_02-12-2019.pdf | 2019-12-02 |
| 20 | 201741014912_Drawings_Granted 326513_02-12-2019.pdf | 2019-12-02 |
| 21 | 201741014912_Description_Granted 326513_02-12-2019.pdf | 2019-12-02 |
| 22 | 201741014912_Claims_Granted 326513_02-12-2019.pdf | 2019-12-02 |
| 23 | 201741014912_Abstract_Granted 326513_02-12-2019.pdf | 2019-12-02 |
| 24 | 201741014912-PatentCertificate02-12-2019.pdf | 2019-12-02 |
| 25 | 201741014912-IntimationOfGrant02-12-2019.pdf | 2019-12-02 |
| 26 | 201741014912-RELEVANT DOCUMENTS [12-03-2020(online)].pdf | 2020-03-12 |
| 27 | 201741014912_Statement of Working_23-09-2021.pdf | 2021-09-23 |
| 28 | 201741014912-OTHERS [26-04-2022(online)].pdf | 2022-04-26 |
| 29 | 201741014912-EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION(S) [26-04-2022(online)].pdf | 2022-04-26 |
| 30 | 201741014912-Form 27_Statement of Working_26-09-2022.pdf | 2022-09-26 |
| 31 | 326513.Form 27.pdf | 2023-11-20 |
| 1 | Search_19-07-2019.pdf |